Misplaced Pages

#467532

50-544: First attached to the Zion's Co-operative Mercantile Institution (ZCMI) building, it was removed when that structure was razed in the 1970s, after which it was restored and attached to the ZCMI Center Mall . In the 2010s, it was then attached to City Creek Center when that development replaced the older mall. The façade is three stories in height, and is divided into three sections, articulated by square columns between them and at

100-628: A 10 percent increase in price, once a state of emergency has been declared.  Unlike other states that require the President of the United States or the state's governor to declare a state of emergency, California permits emergency proclamations by officials, boards, and other governing bodies of cities and counties to trigger C.P.C. § 396.   The prohibition lasts for up to 30 days at a time and may be renewed as necessary.  Since October 2017, then-California Governor Jerry Brown repeatedly extended

150-712: A business can be forced to pay up to 10% of global revenues. Similar to UK regulations, the EU does not include “price gouging” explicitly in regulation. Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union is "aimed at preventing undertakings who hold a dominant position in a market from abusing that position." As stated, “such abuse may, in particular, consist in: (a) directly or indirectly imposing unfair purchase or selling prices or other unfair trading conditions...” In 2016,

200-443: A civil emergency or when it cancels or dishonors contracts in order to take advantage of an increase in prices related to such an emergency. The model case is a retailer who increases the price of existing stocks of milk and bread when a hurricane is imminent. Though the effect of such laws have been proven to actually increase the risk of extreme shortages since the absence of increased prices replaces higher prices with an incentive for

250-612: A competitive free market , or to windfall profits . In some jurisdictions of the United States during civil emergencies, price gouging is a specific crime. Price gouging is considered by some to be exploitative and unethical and by others to be a simple result of supply and demand . Price gouging is similar to profiteering but can be distinguished by being short-term and localized and by being restricted to essentials such as food, clothing, shelter, medicine, and equipment needed to preserve life and property. In jurisdictions where there

300-424: A conglomerate of mercantile companies owned by William Jennings . ZCMI became a formidable business force, eventually manufacturing its own line of boots and shoes, and a line of work clothes. It also sold everything from housing needs, lumber, nails, and the like, to household needs such as fabric, needles, thread, food preservation products, furniture, and draperies, even some beauty products; nearly everything

350-623: A good is valued and that producers can profit by increasing the quantity supplied." A 2022 Working Paper by the International Monetary Fund explores the implementation of windfall profit taxes , which have gained renewed interest following the COVID-19 pandemic, the war in Ukraine, and subsequent surges in energy and food prices. The paper discusses the potential of such taxes as a tool for efficiently taxing economic rents , which are often

400-565: A result of losses for two consecutive years, along with mounting economic and social pressures, ZCMI was sold to May Department Stores Company of St. Louis , ZCMI operated under its original name as a part of May's Portland -based Meier & Frank division until April 2001, when the stores adopted the Meier & Frank name. In addition to the name change, the Utah stores in Logan and St. George , along with

450-536: A result of monopolistic power or unexpected events like pandemics, war, or natural disasters, and contribute to windfall profits. Such profits have raised public and policy concerns about price gouging, where firms are perceived to be profiting excessively from unforeseen circumstances. In Australia in 2023 and 2024, major supermarket chains Coles and Woolworths received criticism as price gouging, especially in less competitive markets. Coles and Woolworths control 65% of Australia's grocery market. In March 2024,

500-466: A shopping mall to replace ZCMI's ageing downtown buildings. These plans called for maintaining the "spirit and semblance" of the historic façade, while demolishing the buildings behind it. This included either saving and restoring the façade, or fabricating a new one made to look like the original. The possibly of a replacement rather than restoration caused a furor in the community. The owners brought in local architect, Steven T. Baird, who determined there

550-440: A short-term change in the demand curve . Price gouging became highly prevalent in news media in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, when state price gouging regulations went into effect due to the national emergency. The rise in public discourse was associated with increased shortages related to the COVID-19 pandemic . The resulting inflation after the pandemic has also been blamed, at least in part, by some on price gouging. During

SECTION 10

#1732851752468

600-400: A specific statute addressing price gouging, can nevertheless have sought to apply its consumer protection act to argue that high prices during COVID-19 for PPE was an "unfair" or "deceptive" practice. Statutory prohibitions on price gouging become effective once a state of emergency has been declared. States have legislated different requirements for who must declare a state of emergency for

650-426: Is a pejorative term used to refer to the practice of increasing the prices of goods , services , or commodities to a level much higher than is considered reasonable or fair by some. This commonly applies to price increases of basic necessities after natural disasters . Usually, this event occurs after a demand or supply shock . The term can also be used to refer to profits obtained by practices inconsistent with

700-665: Is currently attached to the west face of Macy's department store, in the same general location as the original. ZCMI Zion's Co-operative Mercantile Institution ( ZCMI ) was an American department store chain. It was founded in Salt Lake City , Utah , on October 9, 1868, by Brigham Young . For many years it used the slogan, "America's First Department Store." Even though the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) had been headquartered in Salt Lake City for some twenty years by that time, they were despised by

750-401: Is left to state courts to decide. On August 11, 2020, New York Attorney General Letitia James sued Hillandale Farms , one of the largest U.S. egg producers, for allegedly price gouging more than four million cartons of eggs by increasing prices by almost five times during the pandemic. The lawsuit alleges that the price increases were an effort to profit off of higher consumer demand during

800-497: Is no such crime, the term may still be used to pressure firms to refrain from such behavior. The term is used directly in laws and regulations in the United States and Canada, but legislation exists internationally with similar regulatory purpose under existing competition laws. It is sometimes used to refer to practices of a coercive monopoly that prices above the market rate by deliberately curtailing production. Alternatively, it may refer to suppliers' benefiting to excess from

850-572: The American Institute for Economic Research ) in 2020 argue that laws prohibiting price gouging worsen emergencies for both buyers and sellers. In a 2012 survey of leading American economists by the Initiative on Global Markets , only 8 percent agreed with a proposal in Connecticut to prohibit "unconscionably excessive" price increases during severe weather events. Those who disagreed stated that

900-483: The Federal Trade Commission accused grocery chains in the U.S. of price gouging. The Commission also sued to block the proposed acquisition of Albertsons by Kroger citing the need for more competition to keep prices down. A study from 2024 showed that oftentimes when allegations of "price gouging" are made, the profit margins of sellers and vendors is substantially lower than critics believe, such as in

950-407: The 30 days leading up to the emergency declaration. Alabama state law does not define what constitutes a “gross disparity,” making it difficult for either affected residents or law enforcement to determine when price gouging has occurred, while others merely limit vendors and landlords to price increases of less than 25 percent. Enforcement of anti-price gouging statutes can be difficult because of

1000-617: The COVID-19 pandemic. The Online Merchants Guild , a trade association for online merchants, filed a case in Kentucky on the basis that state regulations against price gouging are unconstitutional in the online marketplace since online merchants are unable to control pricing by state. Judge Gregory Van Tatenhove sided with the Online Merchants Guild on June 23, 2020, saying that the Kentucky Attorney General cannot enforce

1050-578: The EU Commissioner for Competition Margrethe Vestager stated that the EU Commission will "intervene directly to correct excessively high prices" specifically within the gas industry, pharmaceutical industry and in cases of abuse of standard-essential patents. On March 13, 2020, a national emergency was declared in the United States by President Trump in response to the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic;

SECTION 20

#1732851752468

1100-791: The Idaho stores in Idaho Falls and Pocatello , were sold to Dillard's in March 2001. May Co. was sold to Federated Department Stores (now Macy's, Inc. ) in 2005. In September 2006, all Meier & Frank stores were converted to Macy's . The façade of ZCMI was used in the City Creek Center , retaining the original ZCMI nameplate as a front for Macy's . Strawbridge's added to division in 1996 Meier & Frank added to division in 2002 ; Zion's Cooperative Mercantile Institution (2001, to Meier & Frank) Price gouging Price gouging

1150-562: The LDS, with Harold Harper Bennett being the first President of the store to not also hold the LDS office. In 1990, ZCMI opened its first concept store called ZCMI II. Featuring a smaller floor plan than its usual stores, this concept sold solely men's and women's clothing and shoes, while lacking other departments such as housewares, linens, and children's clothing. The first of these opened at Tri City Mall in Mesa, Arizona in 1990. In October 1999, as

1200-456: The October 2017 fires. Section 396(e) stipulated, in part, that: “it is unlawful for any person, business, or other entity, to increase the rental price . . . advertised, offered, or charged for housing, to an existing or prospective tenant, by more than 10 percent.”  While the amendment reiterated that landlords may increase the rental price by up to 10 percent if they could demonstrate that

1250-734: The PPE at excessively inflated prices as part of a $ 1.8 million scheme. This case was investigated by the FBI, Veteran's Association, and Fraud Section of the United States Department of Justice. The charges brought were conspiracy to commit wire fraud and mail fraud, conspiracy to defraud the United States, conspiracy to commit hoarding of designated scarce materials, and hoarding of designated scarce materials. Allocative efficiency holds that when prices function properly, markets tend to allocate resources to their most valued uses. In turn, those who value

1300-449: The columns. The middle section cornice includes a fully pedimented gable and is raised above a frieze panel with vine motifs around two circular panels with the dates 1868 and 1999, and a central panel bearing the legend ZCMI. ZCMI was founded in October 1868, and is described as the first department store in the United States. Its flagship store for many decades was opened in downtown Salt Lake City on April 1, 1876. This 1876 building

1350-710: The declaration allowed for an initial $ 50 billion to be used to support states. As studied by the National Institutes of Health , the COVID-19 pandemic induced a panic as mandates were put in place for Americans to stay at home, quarantine, and wear masks. The declared COVID-19 emergency made state-level price gouging laws and regulations go into effect. Demand for certain products increased while supply decreased. Such products in short supply included surgical masks , N95 respirators , hand sanitizer, and toilet paper. More than 30 states' attorneys general urged Facebook , Amazon , Craigslist , eBay , and Walmart to restrict

1400-457: The earliest person to market to obtain all of a product about to imminently experience a period of very high demand. In Florida, it is a defense to show that the price increase mostly reflects increased costs, such as running an emergency generator or hazard pay for workers, while California places a ten percent cap on any increases. Laws and regulations in the United Kingdom do not use

1450-425: The ends. Each section is about 50 feet (15 m) wide and each is composed of seven bays, separated by paneled columns with Corinthian capitals . Above the first two floors there are modillioned cornices separating the floors, with a deeper projecting cornice at the roof level. The roof cornice of the outer levels is further adorned with a layer of dentil work below the modillions, and has brackets above each of

1500-413: The exceptions often contained within the statutes and the lack of oversight mechanisms. Statutes generally give wide discretion not to prosecute. In 2004, Florida determined that one-third of complaints were unfounded, and a large fraction of the remainder was handled by consent decrees , rather than prosecution. California Penal Code 396 prohibits price gouging, generally defined as anything greater than

1550-533: The good the most and are able to afford it will pay a higher price than those who do not value the good as much or who are unable to afford it. According to Friedrich Hayek in " The Use of Knowledge in Society " (1945), prices can act to coordinate the separate actions of different people as they seek to satisfy their desires. Economists such as Thomas Sowell ( Chicago School of economics ) in 2004, Donald J. Boudreaux in 2005, and Raymond Niles (Senior Fellow at

ZCMI Cast Iron Front - Misplaced Pages Continue

1600-577: The increase in costs were directly attributable to repairs, it also clarified what could not justify an increase in rent. An increase in rent may not be “based on the length of the rental term, the inclusion of additional goods or services, except with respect to furniture, or that the rent was offered by, or paid by, an insurance company, or other third party, on behalf of a tenant." Florida's "state of emergency" law criminalizes price gouging. A supplier of essential goods and services may be charged when it sharply raises prices in anticipation of or during

1650-415: The law to go into effect. Some state statutes that prohibit price gouging—including those of Alabama, Florida, Mississippi, and Ohio —prohibit price increases only once the President of the United States or the state's governor has declared a state of emergency in the impacted region. California permits emergency proclamations by officials, boards, and other governing bodies of cities and counties to trigger

1700-527: The law. The District Attorney of Sonoma County has attempted to remedy this by creating its own task force focused on combatting and prosecuting price gouging. In 2018, the California state legislature amended C.P.C. § 396 after the fallout from the 2017 wildfires. District attorneys reached out to legislators explaining how the current language of section 396 made it difficult to enforce. The legislature completely rewrote sections 396(e)-(f). Prior to

1750-485: The mall structure, created a loggia . In October 2006, the church announced it would be tearing down the ZCMI Center Mall and replacing it with a new mixed-use development called City Creek Center . While City Creek Center was built, the façade was dismantled and stored. Following reconditioning by Historical Arts & Casting, Inc., it was reassembled from 2010 to 2011, and City Creek Center opened in March 2012. It

1800-414: The other sections. The restoration also required that the first story of the façade be recast, as it had largely been obliterated when the front was modernized with larger windows. The façade was then reconstructed, in approximately its original location, on the face of the new ZCMI store at the ZCMI Center Mall , with the project completing in 1976. The façade's placement on a steel frame, slightly away from

1850-433: The pandemic, the idea of ' greedflation ' or 'seller's inflation' also moved out of the progressive economics fringe by 2023 to be embraced by some mainstream economists, policymakers and business press. As of March 2021, Proskauer Rose counted 42 states that have emergency regulations or price-gouging statutes. Price-gouging is often defined in terms of the three criteria listed below: Washington state does not have

1900-415: The pandemic. To settle the lawsuit, Hillandale Farms agreed to donate 1.2 million eggs to New York food banks. A Mississippi businessman purchased scarce personal protective equipment (PPE) including gowns, face shields, and masks through his pharmaceutical wholesale company. An indictment alleges that the business then solicited health care providers, including the U.S. Veteran's Association, to purchase

1950-467: The phrase “price gouging” in consumer protection regulation but are similar to U.S. laws. Chapter II of the UK Competition Act 1998 prohibits businesses with market dominance from engaging in "abusive" conduct, including "unfair" pricing. Market dominance is considered when a business has greater than 40% of the market share within their respective industry. In the case of a violation of Chapter II,

2000-686: The pioneers needed to survive and thrive. Based in Salt Lake City, it quickly became a household name in the community. The LDS Church was a significant influence in the company, retaining a majority interest in ZCMI until its eventual sale in December 1999. The store was established by a vote from the Council of Fifty , an early organization in the LDS Church. The President of the store would often also be President of

2050-508: The price gouging regulations on Amazon sellers. The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously overturned that ruling in April of 2021. In response to the issuance of emergency price gouging regulations, multiple state attorneys general and federal agencies have investigated potential cases of price gouging impacting consumers and agencies. Since regulatory measures vary by state, there is no uniform interpretation of price gouging violations, and it

ZCMI Cast Iron Front - Misplaced Pages Continue

2100-526: The price-gouging ban for counties impacted by the October 2017 wildfires and subsequently for the counties impacted by the 2018 wildfires.  One of his last acts as governor was to extend the prohibitions until May 31, 2019. Even though California prohibits price hikes after an emergency is declared, the state, like many others, has virtually no price monitoring structure for oversight. Attorneys and law enforcement generally rely on news reports and word of mouth to learn about price increases that may violate

2150-436: The revisions, those sections of the law had only specified that the prohibitions on price gouging could be extended for additional 30-day periods and that a violation of the law was punishable by imprisonment in a county jail no longer than one year, by a fine no greater than $ 10,000, or both. The amended version went into effect on January 1, 2019 and aimed to reduce future price increases similar to those that had ensued after

2200-445: The selling of necessary products at "unconscionable" prices. A 2018 appeals court overturned a lower court ruling, arguing that the dormant commerce clause of the U.S. constitution meant Maryland's anti-price gouging statute was unconstitutional. This complaint relates to online merchants selling necessary products on Amazon during the US national state of emergency invoked in response to

2250-422: The state's price gouging law. State laws vary on what price increases are permitted during a declared disaster. California has set a 10 percent ceiling on price increases. The law includes exceptions for price increases that can be justified in terms of the increased cost of supply, transportation, demand, or storage. Florida prohibits a price increase “that grossly exceeds the average price” of that same item in

2300-430: The surrounding community, as Young had disparaged non-Mormon merchants who had engaged in price gouging on necessities, and encouraged boycotting these businesses in 1866. Mormon business owners were routinely charged higher prices by wholesalers who discovered they were dealing with Latter-day Saints . Partly because of the impending completion of the railroad, and partly to create a more fair business atmosphere, it

2350-446: The wording was vague or unenforceable, and that restricting price increases leads to misallocation of resources. In 2022, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis economist Christopher J. Neely said that "most economists believe broad price controls to be costly and ineffective in most situations" because high prices function to "allocate scarce goods and services to buyers who are most willing and able to pay for them, [and] they signal that

2400-470: Was Young's idea to encourage Mormon businesses to band together under one roof. By pooling their resources, they were able to make larger orders to sell materials and goods exclusively (at the time) to fellow LDS Church members. ZCMI was formally organized in 1868 and incorporated for a 25-year renewable contract in 1870. The central component of this was the LDS Church's purchase of the Eagle Emporium,

2450-447: Was designed by local architects William Folsom and Obed Taylor , and at first featured only the central portion of the façade, which was fashioned out of cast iron. During two building expansions, occurring in 1880 and 1901, the façade was extended, the first time also in cast iron, the second time in stamped sheet metal. In May 1969, ZCMI's owner, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church), announced plans to develop

2500-400: Was enough historic fabric remaining that the façade could be restored rather than replaced; a process he would oversee. In October 1973, disassembly of the façade began. The pieces were inspected and multiple layers of paint removed. Since the northern section had been made of sheet metal, a cast iron replacement was created, which also afforded the opportunity to match it with the proportions of

#467532