Misplaced Pages

Whitehall Conference

Article snapshot taken from Wikipedia with creative commons attribution-sharealike license. Give it a read and then ask your questions in the chat. We can research this topic together.

The Whitehall Conference was a gathering of prominent English merchants , clergymen , and lawyers convened by Oliver Cromwell for the purpose of debating whether Jews should be readmitted to England . The conference lasted from 4 to 18 December 1655.

#717282

82-443: While Cromwell himself was in favour of Jewish resettlement , the participants ultimately broke down into three groups. The London merchants opposed resettlement due to fears of economic competition, while the clergymen were not in favour on religious grounds. The second group, consisting mainly of Cromwell's officials and military figures, backed readmission with certain precautions built in. They were in favour of giving Jews

164-500: A cataclysm of heresy and destruction, until the final destruction of evil and the final destruction of the spirit of evil by a triumphant king of peace at the end of the final millennial age. Scholars have also linked various other social and political movements, both religious and secular , to millennialist metaphors. Most Christian millennialist thinking is based upon the Book of Revelation , specifically Revelation 20, which describes

246-510: A date somewhat before the September equinox in Nuremberg . In a speech held on 27 November 1937, Hitler commented on his plans to have major parts of Berlin torn down and rebuilt : [...] einem tausendjährigen Volk mit tausendjähriger geschichtlicher und kultureller Vergangenheit für die vor ihm liegende unabsehbare Zukunft eine ebenbürtige tausendjährige Stadt zu bauen [...]. [...] to build

328-555: A few years previously had already started admitting Jews escaping from the Portuguese reconquest of Dutch Brazil ), where he explored the possibility of Jews setting in Jamaica . There they would be offered full civil rights and even land grants. There is some difference of opinion as to Oliver Cromwell’s opinions regarding the readmission of the Jews. It has been pointed out that he held many of

410-624: A further attempt was made by the Earl of Berkshire and Paul Ricaut to bring about the expulsion of the Jews, but the King-in-Council assured the latter of the continuance of former favour. Similar appeals to prejudice were made in 1673, when Jews, for meeting in Duke's Place for a religious service, were indicted on a charge of rioting, and in 1685, when thirty-seven were arrested on the Royal Exchange; but

492-592: A heavenly calling, to gain everlasting life on Earth during the Millennium. Jehovah's Witnesses believe that Christ will rule from heaven for 1,000 years as king over the earth, assisted by the 144,000 ascended humans. According to them this 1,000 year reign the earth will become a paradise, like the Garden of Eden, and humans will themselves return to the perfection lost by Adam and Eve. Also known as Eastern Lightning, The Church of Almighty God mentions in its teachings

574-405: A little while. The Book of Revelation then describes a series of judges who are seated on thrones, as well as John's vision of the souls of those who were beheaded for their testimony in favor of Jesus and their rejection of the mark of the beast. These souls: came to life and reigned with Christ a thousand years. (The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended.) This

656-505: A millennial city adequate [in splendour] to a thousand-year-old people with a thousand-year-old historical and cultural past, for its never-ending [glorious] future [...] After Adolf Hitler's unsuccessful attempt to implement a thousand-year-reign, the Vatican issued an official statement that millennial claims could not be safely taught and that the related scriptures in Revelation (also called

738-557: A probationary period during which they could be expelled if they misbehaved. They were expected not to blaspheme Christ or attempt to convert Christians . The third group consisted of the Millenarians and Sabbatarians , both of whom broke down into radical and more conservative wings. The conservative wing of this faction supported readmission with clauses built in that would make it possible for Jews to be thrown out if things did not go as planned. The radical wing argued that it

820-551: A rabbi of the Jewish nation, well respected for his learning and good affection to the State, to come from Amsterdam to these parts." Fearing local anti-English opinion so soon after war, ben Israel turned down the invitation. But by the middle of the decade, Cromwell was taking advice from Marrano trader Simon de Caceres . At de Caceres' suggestion, Cromwell dispatched Marrano physician Abraham de Mercado and his son Raphael to Barbados (which

902-427: A religious foundation, but they must have a vision of an apocalypse that can be utopian or dystopian . Those associated with millennial social movements are "prone to [be violent]", with certain types of millennialism connected to violence. In progressive millennialism, the "transformation of the social order is gradual and humans play a role in fostering that transformation". Catastrophic millennialism "deems

SECTION 10

#1732852475718

984-516: A search for union of believers, rather than toleration of differing beliefs, and religious persecution was the largest obstacle to this union. However, liberty of conscience extended only to "God's peculiar" and not heretics (such as Quakers , Socinians , and Ranters ). There was a great increase of religious freedom and the ecclesiastical diversity in Cromwellian England. This marked a revolutionary change and led to increasing toleration in

1066-739: A secular messianism. The Bible Student movement is a millennialist movement based on views expressed in "The Divine Plan of the Ages," in 1886, in Volume One of the Studies in the Scriptures series, by Pastor Charles Taze Russell . (This series is still being published, since 1927, by the Dawn Bible Students Association .) Bible Students believe that there will be a universal opportunity for every person, past and present, not previously recipients of

1148-424: A thousand years to come ( Tausendjähriges Reich ) but ultimately lasted for only 12 years (1933–1945). The German thinker Arthur Moeller van den Bruck coined the phrase "Third Reich" and in 1923 published a book titled Das Dritte Reich . Looking back at German history , he distinguished two separate periods, and identified them with the ages of the 12th-century Italian theologian Joachim of Fiore : After

1230-517: A view to converting them in the 1630s. So, by the 1640s, the imminent conversion of the Jews was a widespread belief among Puritans. Indeed during that decade the Christians who were most liberal towards Jews are also those who were most committed to their conversion. A number of these ‘admissionists’ were close to Cromwell, including John Sadler , John Dury , and Hugh Peter . Other notable readmissionists include exiled Royalist cleric Thomas Barlow and

1312-460: Is called " historic premillennialism ", and it was supported in the early church by Papias , Irenaeus , Justin Martyr , Tertullian , Polycarp , Pseudo-Barnabas , Methodius , Lactantius , Commodianus , Theophilus , Melito , Hippolytus of Rome , Victorinus of Pettau , Nepos , Julius Africanus , Tatian and Montanus . However, the premillennial views of Montanus probably affected

1394-580: Is currently alive and in occultation . Bahá'u'lláh mentioned in the Kitáb-i-Íqán that God will renew the "City of God" about every thousand years, and specifically mentioned that a new Manifestation of God would not appear within 1,000 years (1852–2852 CE) of Bahá'u'lláh's Dispensation , but that the authority of Bahá'u'lláh's message could last up to 500,000 years. The Theosophist Alice Bailey taught that The Christ or The World Teacher would return "sometime after AD 2025", and that this would be

1476-466: Is generally seen as a part of a current of religious and intellectual thought moving towards liberty of conscience , encompassing philosemitic millenarianism and Hebraicism , as well as political and trade interests favouring Jewish presence in England. The schools of thought that led to the resettlement of the Jews in England is the most heavily studied subject of Anglo-Jewish history in the period before

1558-433: Is reckoned that there were about 20 New Christian families living in the city.) As a consequence, a national conference was summoned at Whitehall in the early part of December, which included some of the most eminent lawyers, clergymen, and merchants in the country. The lawyers declared no opposition to the Jews' residing in England, but both the clergymen and merchants were opposed to readmission, leading Cromwell to stop

1640-513: Is the first resurrection. Blessed and holy are those who share in the first resurrection. Over these the second death has no power, but they will be priests of God and of Christ, and they will reign with him a thousand years During the first centuries after Christ, various forms of chiliasm (millennialism) were to be found in the Church, both East and West . Premillennialism held by the Early Church

1722-577: The Commons in 1745 and 1746, but failed to pass the Lords in 1747; it was ultimately dropped. Meanwhile, during the Jacobite rising of 1745 the Jews had shown particular loyalty to the government. Their chief financier, Samson Gideon , had strengthened the stock market, and several of the younger members had volunteered in the corps raised to defend London. The meeting between Menasseh Ben Israel and Oliver Cromwell

SECTION 20

#1732852475718

1804-778: The Greek equivalent) is a belief which is held by some religious denominations . According to this belief, a Messianic Age will be established on Earth prior to the Last Judgment and the future permanent state of "eternity". Christianity and Judaism have both produced messianic movements which featured millennialist teachings—such as the notion that an earthly kingdom of God was at hand. These millenarian movements often led to considerable social unrest. Similarities to millennialism also exist in Zoroastrianism , which identified successive thousand-year periods, each of which will end in

1886-658: The New Age equivalent of the Christian concept of the Second Coming of Christ . Note that the being she speaks of The World Teacher is the same as that spiritual being best known to other Theosophists as Maitreya . Millennial social movements, a specific form of millenarianism , have as their basis some concept of a cycle of one-thousand years. Sometimes the two terms are used as synonyms, but purists regard this as not entirely accurate. Millennial social movements need not have

1968-583: The Royal Exchange as a duly licensed broker of the City of London, without taking the usual oath involving a statement of faith in Christianity (when he was finally sworn in in 1668, the oath was changed for him). Carvajal had previously been granted letters of denization for himself and his son, which guaranteed certain rights of citizenship. During the years 1655–56 the question of the return of Jews to England

2050-459: The Rump Parliament repealed the recusancy laws in 1650). This was partly due to the impossibility of stopping religious free expression, but it also became a part of the cause of the new model army . The doctrinal policies of the protectorate were largely conservative. However, this Puritan train of thought could also point towards liberty of conscience. For Congregationalists , truth lay in

2132-777: The Spanish Main from the Netherlands to England. The mission of Oliver St John to Amsterdam, though failing to establish a coalition between English and Dutch commercial interests as an alternative to the Navigation Act, had negotiated with Menasseh Ben Israel and the Amsterdam community. A pass was granted to Menasseh to enter England, but he was unable to use it because of the First Anglo-Dutch War , which lasted from 1652 to 1654. The years 1655 and 1656 were to prove decisive in

2214-675: The descendants of the Ten lost tribes of Israel , with Cromwell himself numbering amongst the supporters of this idea. After both the Alhambra Decree of 1492, which expelled Jews from Spain in 1492, and similar measures in Portugal in 1496, some converso traders (Jewish converts to Christianity, who often practised Judaism in secret, sometimes also known as New Christians or derogatively as Marranos ) settled in London and Bristol. The small community

2296-887: The Age of Millennial Kingdom, which will follow the catastrophes prophesied in the Book of Revelation in the Bible. Counter to much of the Pentecostal movement, which tends towards belief in premillennialism, the rise of the Antichrist, and the decay of the world prior to the Second Coming, the New Apostolic Reformation 's focus is instead on an "optimistic" eschatology. It holds that most end-time prophecies have long since been fulfilled and that modern-day prophets and apostles have divine authority;

2378-594: The Apocalypse) should be understood spiritually. Catholic author Bernard LeFrois wrote: Millenium [ sic ]: [...] Since the Holy Office decreed (July 21, 1944) that it cannot be safely taught that Christ at His Second Coming will reign visibly with only some of His saints (risen from the dead) for a period of time before the final and universal judgment, a spiritual millenium is to be seen in Apoc. 20:4–6. St. John gives

2460-963: The Cartwrights never received an answer. The following year Amsterdam-based Rabbi and diplomat Menasseh Ben Israel wrote in his book Hope of Israel of the necessity of the Jews being "spread out to the ends of the earth" (Daniel 12:7) before they could be redeemed. The book was originally published in Dutch and Latin in 1650, and then in English (dedicated to Parliament and the Council of State) in 1652. In 1651 Ben Israel met Oliver St John and his envoys on their mission to secure an Anglo-Dutch coalition. The English were impressed by learning and manner, and advised him to formally apply for Jewish readmission to England. In 1653, at Oliver St John’s suggestion, Cromwell issued an official directive to authorise, "Menasseh ben Israel,

2542-475: The Dissenter Henry Jessey . The Fifth Monarchy Men were another example of Puritan millenarians who saw the readmission of the Jews as hastening the kingdom of Christ. The exiled Royalist Sir Edward Nicholas is one of the few admissionists who did not seem interested in conversion. By contrast, the anti-admissionists were often animated by the belief that it would be difficult or impossible to convert

Whitehall Conference - Misplaced Pages Continue

2624-399: The English throne by a loan of 2,000,000 guilders from Francisco Lopes Suasso (1614–1685) (of the well-known Lopes Suasso family), later made first Baron d'Avernas le Gras by Charles II of Spain . William did not interfere when in 1689 some of the chief Jewish merchants of London were forced to pay the duty levied on the goods of aliens, but he refused a petition from Jamaica to expel

2706-500: The Jews as the true Israel of the Bible. Indeed, they saw the Jews as a superior group, sharing some characteristics with the chosen nation of England. This belief was rooted in the literal interpretation of the Biblical primacy of the Jews found in the writings of Thomas Brightman . This meant that if the Jews were specially favoured by God, the English must listen to their appeals for help. These philo-semitic figures, who also believed in

2788-568: The Jews in England The resettlement of the Jews in England was an informal arrangement during the Commonwealth of England in the mid-1650s, which allowed Jews to practice their faith openly. It forms a prominent part of the history of the Jews in England . It happened directly after two events. Firstly a prominent rabbi Menasseh ben Israel came to the country from the Netherlands to make

2870-468: The Jews, his presence gave prominent Englishmen a positive impression of learning and virtue among Jews. Early in the following year (1656), the question came to a practical issue through the declaration of war against Spain , which resulted in the arrest of Antonio Rodrigues Robles , one of the community of Iberian New Christians who traded between London and the Canary Islands. Robles petitioned for

2952-587: The Jews. William Prynne ’s anti-Semitic pamphlet A Short Demurrer , which was printed on the eve of the Whitehall Conference, and the pamphlet Anglo-Judaeus or The History of the Jews Whilst Here in England by W.H. both doubt that the Jews would be converted once in England. Many millenarians at the time emphasised the chosen role of England in God’s plan, and this was often accompanied by the identification

3034-471: The Jews. William's reign brought about a closer connection between the predominantly Sephardic communities of London and Amsterdam; this aided in the transfer of the European finance centre from the Dutch capital to the English capital. Over this time a small German Ashkenazi community had arrived and established their own synagogue in 1692, but they were of little mercantile consequence, and did not figure in

3116-553: The Mahdi will rule for a period of time before the Day of Judgement . The Mahdi is noted in the Sunni books, Sunan Abi Dawud 4285, Sunan Ibn Majah 4083, and Sahih Muslim 2913. Shia and Sunni Muslims differ on who exactly the Mahdi is. While they both agree that he will come alongside Jesus to save mankind from injustice and oppression; Sunnis believe he is yet to be born, while Shias believe that he

3198-669: The Nazi authorities banned the informal use of "Third Reich" throughout the German press in the summer of 1939, instructing it to use more official terms such as "German Reich", "Greater German Reich", and "National Socialist Germany" exclusively. During the early part of the Third Reich many Germans also referred to Hitler as being the German Messiah , especially when he conducted the Nuremberg rallies , which came to be held annually (1933–1938) at

3280-518: The Pope as antichrist , came to replace antisemitism. The period of the English Civil Wars and Interregnum was marked by both widespread millennial beliefs and a beginning of religious tolerance. Significantly, millenarianism in England often had a strong Hebraist character, that emphasised the study of Hebrew and Judaism. This was sometimes extended by certain individuals to claim the English as

3362-577: The autumn Moses Athias moved from Hamburg to act as religious preceptor. By December 1656 they had rented a house for use as a synagogue, and services began in January of 1657. In February of 1657 the new community, represented by Antonio Fernandez Carvajal and Simon de Caceres , acquired land near Mile End for use as a Synagogue. Historian Todd Endelman makes the point that it is unlikely this activity could have happened without Cromwell’s permission that they could live as professing Jews. The informal nature of

Whitehall Conference - Misplaced Pages Continue

3444-406: The case for Jewish resettlement, and secondly a Spanish New Christian (a supposedly converted Jew, who secretly practised his religion) merchant Antonio Robles requested that he be classified as a Jew rather than Spaniard during the war between England and Spain . Historians have disagreed about the reasons behind the resettlement, particularly regarding Oliver Cromwell 's motives, but the move

3526-537: The concept of the end of the world coming unexpectedly, "like a thief in the night", and the concept of "the antichrist " were almost universally held). Millennialist theories try to explain what this "1000 years of Satan bound in chains" would be like. Various types of millennialism exist with regard to Christian eschatology , especially within Protestantism , such as Premillennialism , Postmillennialism , and Amillennialism . The first two refer to different views of

3608-512: The current social order as irrevocably corrupt, and total destruction of this order is necessary as the precursor to the building of a new, godly order". However the link between millennialism and violence may be problematic, as new religious movements may stray from the catastrophic view as time progresses. The most controversial interpretation of the three-age system and of millennialism in general involves Adolf Hitler 's " Third Reich " ( Drittes Reich ), which in his vision would last for

3690-406: The discussion to prevent an adverse decision. Nonetheless, some change to official policy must have occurred, because the diarist John Evelyn wrote in his diary on 14 December, "Now were the Jews admitted". Ben Israel stayed in England until September 1657, during which time he met and engaged with a number of influential people. Although he did not achieve a legal ruling on the resettlement of

3772-554: The eighteenth century. In 1290, King Edward I of England had issued an edict expelling all Jews from England . However the English Reformation , which started in the 1530s, brought a number of changes that benefited Jews in the long term. Doctrines and rituals of the Roman Catholic church that insulted Jews were eliminated, especially those that emphasised their role in the death of Jesus. Further anti-Catholicism , with

3854-565: The end times will be an era in which obedient Christians, through using spiritual warfare and shaping all aspects of society into aligning with their Christian beliefs ( Seven Mountain Mandate ), will bring about the Second Coming. Millennialist thinking first emerged in Jewish apocryphal literature of the tumultuous Second Temple period , Gerschom Scholem profiles medieval and early modern Jewish millennialist teachings in his book Sabbatai Sevi,

3936-788: The field was the MP and jurist John Selden , whose thought was influenced by Thomas Erastus and Grotius . Selden proposed minimal government intervention on matters of religion, a view he modelled on the Hebrew Commonwealth . He in turn influenced similar approaches in John Milton (whose plea for freedom of the press, the Areopagitica (1644), directly named him), Thomas Hobbes and James Harrington (the latter of whom proposed settling Jews in Ireland in his book The Commonwealth of Oceana ). Overall

4018-426: The following shows: The Antichrist's deception already begins to take shape in the world every time the claim is made to realize within history that messianic hope which can only be realized beyond history through the eschatological judgment. The Church has rejected even modified forms of this falsification of the kingdom to come under the name of millenarianism, especially the "intrinsically perverse" political form of

4100-560: The future order of events diversified after the Protestant reformation ( c.  1517 ). In particular, new emphasis was placed on the passages in the Book of Revelation which seemed to say that as Christ would return to judge the living and the dead, Satan would be locked away for 1000 years, but then released on the world to instigate a final battle against God and his Saints . Previous Catholic and Orthodox theologians had no clear or consensus view on what this actually meant (only

4182-775: The history of the resettlement of the Jews in England. The first of these was the visit of Menasseh ben Israel and the second was the case of the Marrano trader Antonio Rodrigues Robles. Menasseh ben Israel's son Samuel had arrived in England accompanied by trader David Dormido in 1653 to investigate the possibility of the resettlement of the Jews. In May 1655, he was sent back to Amsterdam in order to try to convince his father to visit England. The rabbi came to England in September 1655 with three other local rabbis, where they were lodged as guests of Cromwell. There he printed his "humble address" to Cromwell. (When ben Israel began his stay in London it

SECTION 50

#1732852475718

4264-632: The interval of the Weimar Republic (1918 onwards), during which constitutionalism , parliamentarianism and even pacifism dominated, these were then to be followed by: Although van den Bruck was unimpressed by Hitler when he met him in 1922 and did not join the Nazi Party , nevertheless the Nazis adopted the term "Third Reich" to label the totalitarian state they wanted to set up when they gained power, which they succeeded in doing in 1933 . Later, however,

4346-420: The later rejection of premillennialism in the Church, as Montanism was seen as a heresy. In the 2nd century, the Alogi (those who rejected all of John's writings) were amillennial , as was Caius in the first quarter of the 3rd century. With the influence of Platonism , Clement of Alexandria and Origen denied premillennialism. Likewise, Dionysius of Alexandria (died 264) argued that Revelation

4428-431: The millennium) will be spiritual in and through the church . Amillennialism sees the 1000 year kingdom as being metaphorically described in Rev. 20:1–6 in which "Christ's reign" is current in and through the church. Thus, while this view does not hold to a future millennial reign, it does hold that the New Heavens and New Earth will appear upon the return of Christ. The Catholic Church strongly condemns millennialism as

4510-449: The mystical messiah , which focuses on the 17th-century movement centered on the self-proclaimed messiahship (1648) of Sabbatai Zevi (1626–1676) The Prophet Muhammad has stated that a man from his Household will come and rid the world of all injustice and tyranny. He will be known as the Mahdi . Muslims also believe that Jesus will come alongside the Mahdi and will fight together with him against oppression and injustice, where

4592-402: The petition of the merchants of London asking him to revoke Cromwell's concession. He had been assisted during his exile by several Jews of royalist sympathies, such as Andrea Mendes da Costa ( Chamberlain of Catherine of Braganza , wife of Charles II), Antonio Mendes (the physician brother of Andrea, who had cured Catherine of erysipelas while in Portugal) and Augustine Coronel-Chacon. In 1664

4674-440: The proceedings in both cases were put a stop to by direction of the Privy Council . The status of the Jews was still very indeterminate, with the Attorney-General declaring that they resided in England only under an implied licence. As a matter of fact, the majority of them were still legally aliens and liable to all the disabilities that condition carried with it. William III is reported to have been assisted in his ascent to

4756-429: The pure and pious faith, and are true Christians, think otherwise." Augustine in his early days affirmed premillennialism , but later changed to amillennialism, causing the view to become popularized together with Pope Gregory the Great . The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that the 2nd-century proponents of various Gnostic beliefs (themselves considered heresies) also rejected millenarianism. Christian views on

4838-467: The readmission of the Jews using this same tolerant approach, as well as believing that it would improve trade (he saw the Jews as an important part of Amsterdam’s financial success). Competition with the Dutch for trade and the increasingly protectionist commercial policy that led to the Navigation Act in October 1651 made Oliver Cromwell want to attract the rich Jews of Amsterdam to London so that they might transfer their important trade interests with

4920-460: The relations between the established Jewish community and the government. One of the rabbi was Solomon Ayllon . Early in the eighteenth century the Jewish community of London comprised representatives of the chief Jewish financiers in northern Europe; these included the Mendez da Costa , Abudiente (later known as Gideon and Eardley), Salvador , Lopez , Fonseca, and Seixas families. The utility of these prominent Jewish merchants and financiers

5002-441: The relationship between the "millennial Kingdom" and Christ's second coming. Premillennialism sees Christ's second advent as preceding the millennium, thereby separating the Second Coming from the Final Judgment . In this view, "Christ's reign" will be physically on the earth. Postmillennialism sees Christ's second coming as subsequent to the millennium and concurrent with the final judgment. In this view "Christ's reign" (during

SECTION 60

#1732852475718

5084-400: The resettlement also meant the forces ranged against it had no target and never united to form any significant opposition. Further, at a later date it meant there were no restrictive laws to repeal when Jews wanted fuller citizenship rights. By the end of the decade the number of Jewish families had risen to thirty five. In 1657 Solomon Dormido , a nephew of Menasseh Ben Israel, was admitted to

5166-458: The restoration of the Jews to the Holy Land, included Jeremiah Burroughs , Peter Bulkeley (whose father had given Brightman’s funeral sermon), John Fenwicke , and John Cotton . The original petition for readmission was submitted by Johanna and Ebenezer Cartwright, two English baptists living in Amsterdam, to Thomas Fairfax ’s Council of War in January 1649. As well as asking that Jews be allowed to live in England, their petition also expressed

5248-431: The return of his seized property on account of his being ‘of the Hebrew nation’ rather than Spanish. At the same time six leading members of the New Christian community petitioned Cromwell for permission to gather to worship and acquire a burial ground. Although no formal permission was granted, some assurances must have been given because in the summer Menasseh asked for the Torah scroll to be sent over from Amsterdam, and in

5330-449: The same hopes regarding the readmission and conversion of the Jews as the millenarians. Paul Rycaut , later ambassador to the port of Smyrna recalled the Whitehall Conference, "When they all met, he (Cromwell) ordered the Jews to speak for themselves. After that he turned to the clergy, who inveigled much against the Jews as a cruel and cursed people. Cromwell in his answer to the Clergy called them ‘Men of God’ and desired to be informed by

5412-408: The spirit rather than institutions. Like the Platonists , they searched for internal unity amidst external diversity. Further, Puritans valued conscience, which could be neither forced nor tested, over ritual and ceremony. So rather than toleration, the key debate among key figures in the Protectorate revolved around liberty of conscience . For Blair Worden , Cromwell’s religious policy was rooted in

5494-449: The strongest political group of the 1640s and 50s, the English Puritans, had a negative view of toleration, seeing it as a concession to evil and heresy. It was often associated with tolerating the heresies of Arminianism , the philosophy of free will and free thought, and Socinianism , a doctrine of Anti-trinitarianism . But despite this Puritan hostility to toleration, England did see a certain religious laissez-faire emerge (for instance,

5576-444: The vision of an angel who descends from heaven with a large chain and a key to a bottomless pit, and captures Satan, imprisoning him for a thousand years: He seized the dragon, that ancient serpent, who is the Devil and Satan, and bound him for a thousand years and threw him into the pit and locked and sealed it over him, so that he would deceive the nations no more, until the thousand years were ended. After that, he must be let out for

5658-648: The whether it was not their opinion that the Jews were one day to be called into the Church? He then desired to know whether it was not every Christian man’s duty to forward that good end all he could?… was it not then our duty… to encourage them to settle ere where they could be taught the thuth…[sic]" It has also been pointed out that Cromwell held more practical beliefs. Cromwell believed that Jews could be used as skilled purveyors of foreign intelligence (which would assist his territorial ambitions). Further, toleration of Protestant sects made political sense for Cromwell as it prevented disorder and promoted harmony. He justified

5740-410: The wish that the Jews "shall come to know the Emanuell" and that they be transported to the "Land promised to their fore-fathers". It can be seen as a distillation of the Judeo-centric trends of Puritan thought that had developed over the previous century since John Bale (1495–1563). However, the petition was sent the day before the high court was established to try Charles I , so in the ensuing turmoil

5822-413: The words "on the true faith of a Christian", when registering their title. Only once more would this allowance be made in the passage of the Plantation Act 1740 , but more significantly the act allowed Jews who had or would have resided in British America for seven years to become naturalised British subjects. Shortly afterwards a similar bill was introduced into the Irish Parliament , where it passed

5904-798: The years after the interregnum ended. On the one hand, the loosely Calvinist Cromwell allowed the punishment of men such as the Unitarian John Biddle and the Quaker James Nayler , and accepted the restrictions on religious tolerance found in the Humble Petition and Advice of 1657. But on the other hand, his entourage included men who wanted more liberty of belief than he allowed. These non-sectarian ‘merciful men’ or politiques , who wanted to understand and tolerate beliefs different to their own, included Bulstrode Whitelocke , Matthew Hale , and Sir Charles Worsley . The toleration of Jews

5986-423: Was England's divine duty to readmit Jews, or else face God's wrath. Most members of this third faction hoped to convert Jews to Christianity upon their arrival in England, thereby hastening the second coming and the advent of the messianic age. While the conference failed to reach a definitive conclusion as to whether Jewish readmission should be carried out, it was significant for clarifying that resettlement

6068-548: Was fought in a pamphlet war . Conservative opponents including William Prynne opposed the return while the Quaker Margaret Fell was in favour. Christian supporters believed the conversion of Jews was a sign of the end times and the readmission to England was a step towards that goal. This method of debate had the advantage of not raising antisemitic feelings too strongly; and it likewise enabled Charles II , on his Restoration in 1660, to avoid taking any action on

6150-416: Was largely borne by the hope of converting them to Christianity . Leonard Busher was one of the first to call for the readmission of the Jews to England and the toleration of their faith in 1616. Lawyer and MP, Henry Finch and the scholar Joseph Mede both wrote of the benefits of the conversion of the Jews in the 1620s. The Scottish minister John Wemyss advocated readmitting Jews to Christian lands with

6232-601: Was largely linked by trade to Antwerp, and was expelled altogether in 1609. It was with London’s growing importance as a trading city that Jews from the Netherlands began to settle in the country once more from the 1630s. It is from this first that the current Jewish population of the UK has grown. The 1640s and 1650s in England were marked by intense debates about religious tolerance, marked by speeches and tracts by radical puritans and dissenters who called for liberty of conscience. This extreme diversity of opinion about religious toleration

6314-499: Was legally permissible. Most prominent legal scholars agreed that " there is no law against their (the Jews) coming ". This was correct, as Jews had been expelled from England by the Edict of Expulsion in 1290 on the basis of a royal decree, not on the basis of parliamentary legislation. This finding would prove crucial to the eventual readmission of Jews in the 1660s. Resettlement of

6396-482: Was not written by John and could not be interpreted literally; he was amillennial. Justin Martyr (died 165), who had chiliastic tendencies in his theology, mentions differing views in his Dialogue with Trypho the Jew , chapter 80: "I and many others are of this opinion [premillennialism], and [believe] that such will take place, as you assuredly are aware; but, on the other hand, I signified to you that many who belong to

6478-628: Was painted by Solomon Alexander Hart in 1873 and bought by Sir Francis Goldsmid . The historical figure of Menasseh Ben Israel and the admission of Sephardic Jews from the Netherlands into England are featured in the novel The Weight of Ink by Rachel Kadish (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2017.). Millennialism —  Events  — —  Figures  — —  Events and terms  — —  Events  — Millennialism (from Latin mille  'thousand' annus  'year' and -ism ) or chiliasm (from

6560-523: Was sorted into 12 schools of thought in the seminal study of the period by W.K. Jordan . John Coffey uses a simpler three-point schema: anti-tolerationists, conservative tolerationists, and radical tolerationists, pointing out that although the latter were in a minority, they formed an important part of the debate. Nonetheless it is important to remember that although figures such as William Walwyn , Henry Vane , John Milton , and others made powerful apologia for religious toleration, their frame of reference

6642-498: Was theological, rather than secular in nature and they were not calling for religious pluralism as is understood today. The early and mid Seventeenth century was also marked by a rise in Hebraism, the study of Jewish scriptures, which were often used to discuss political issues such as the existence of a monarchy or republic, and religious toleration. This debate used Jewish sources to justify its conclusions. The most prominent scholar in

6724-475: Was widely recognised. Marlborough in particular made great use of the services of Sir Solomon de Medina , and indeed was publicly charged with taking an annual subvention from him. The early merchants of the resettlement are estimated to have brought with them a capital of £1,500,000 into the country; this amount is estimated to have increased to £5,000,000 by the middle of the 18th century. As early as 1723 an act of Parliament allowed Jews holding land to omit

#717282