Misplaced Pages

#24975

70-598: The focus of the movement is on providing legal support for residents on housing issues, fighting for the rights of its members in relation to government housing policies, as well as conducting workshops and democratic discussions about housing issues. The movement claims to be a socialist movement that believes in direct democracy through open mass meetings with all members invited. Mandela Park Backyarders have alleged widespread corruption in government housing allocation in Mandela Park. They have been successful in compelling

140-422: A trilemma due to the presence of three desirable characteristics of an ideal system of direct democracy, which are challenging to deliver all at once. These three characteristics are participation – widespread participation in the decision-making process by the people affected; deliberation – a rational discussion where all major points of view are weighted according to evidence; and equality – all members of

210-472: A veto on laws adopted by the elected legislature, as in Switzerland . A citizen-initiated referendum, also called an initiative , empowers members of the general public to propose, by petition, specific statutory measures or constitutional reforms to the government and, as with other referendums, the vote may be binding or simply advisory. Initiatives may be direct or indirect: with the direct initiative,

280-451: A certain number of voters could make a request to amend a constitutional article, or even to introduce a new article into the constitution. This mechanism is called federal popular initiative . Thus, partial revisions of the constitution could – from this time onward – be made at any time. Twelve such changes were made in the period of 1893 to 1994 (with no changes during the thirty-year period of 1950–1980): The Federal Constitution

350-442: A cost of sacrificing equality, because if widespread participation is allowed, sufficient resources rarely will be available to compensate people who sacrifice their time to participate in the deliberation. Therefore, participants tend to be those with a strong interest in the issue to be decided and often will not therefore be representative of the overall population. Fishkin instead argues that random sampling should be used to select

420-575: A drastic contrast with the previous Swiss constitutions which were mostly oriented toward the internal isolationism. The new preamble also provides a provision about responsibility before and the rights of the future generations of the people of Switzerland. The general provisions contained in Title 1 (articles 1–6) define the characteristic traits of the Swiss state on all of its three levels of authority: federal, cantonal and municipal . They contain an enumeration of

490-465: A few other nations. Kobach states at the end of his book, "Too often, observers deem Switzerland an oddity among political systems. It is more appropriate to regard it as a pioneer." Finally, the Swiss political system, including its direct democratic devices in a multi-level governance context, becomes increasingly interesting for scholars of European Union integration. In the New England region of

560-608: A form of indirect initiative. A deliberative referendum is a referendum that increases public deliberation through purposeful institutional design. Power of recall gives the public the power to remove elected officials from office before the end of their designated standard term of office. Mandatory referendums correspond to majority rule while optional referendums and popular initiatives correspond to consensus democracy (e.g. Switzerland). One strand of thought sees direct democracy as common and widespread in pre-state societies. The earliest well-documented direct democracy

630-418: A like discrimination. A landed interest, a manufacturing interest, a mercantile interest, a moneyed interest, with many lesser interests, grow up of necessity in civilized nations, and divide them into different classes, actuated by different sentiments and views. The regulation of these various and interfering interests forms the principal task of modern legislation and involves the spirit of party and faction in

700-514: A majority of individuals voting, and also by a majority of cantons. Thus, in Switzerland, a citizen-proposed amendment to the federal constitution (i.e. popular initiative ) cannot be passed at the federal level if a majority of the people approve but a majority of the cantons disapprove. For referendums or propositions in general terms (like the principle of a general revision of the Constitution),

770-705: A majority of those voting is sufficient (Swiss Constitution, 2005). In 1890, when the provisions for Swiss national citizen lawmaking were being debated by civil society and government, the Swiss adopted the idea of double majorities from the United States Congress , in which House votes were to represent the people and Senate votes were to represent the states . According to its supporters, this "legitimacy-rich" approach to national citizen lawmaking has been very successful. Kris Kobach , former Kansas elected official, claims that Switzerland has had tandem successes both socially and economically which are matched by only

SECTION 10

#1732858856025

840-456: A representative random sample of people chosen to take part in the discussion. In the definition used by scholars such as James Fishkin , deliberative democracy is a form of direct democracy which satisfies the requirement for deliberation and equality but does not make provision to involve everyone who wants to be included in the discussion. Participatory democracy , by Fishkin's definition, allows inclusive participation and deliberation, but at

910-492: A sign of acknowledging gender discrimination in the past (Switzerland became the second to last country in Europe that granted, in 1971 , suffrage to women). The new Constitution also eliminated some archaisms of the old Constitution, such as the tax upon bride moving into bridegroom's house, prohibition on cantons to have military forces of more than 300 people, the mandate for cantons to provide each other with military assistance, and

980-412: A small, but still representative, number of people from the general public. Fishkin concedes it is possible to imagine a system that transcends the trilemma, but it would require very radical reforms if such a system were to be integrated into mainstream politics. Democratic schools modeled on Summerhill School resolve conflicts and make school policy decisions through full school meetings in which

1050-517: A solemn invocation of God in continuance of Swiss constitutional tradition. It is a mandate to the State authorities by the Swiss people and cantons, as the Confederation's constituent powers, to adhere to the values listed in the preamble, which include " liberty and democracy , independence and peace in solidarity and openness towards the world". The latter provision about the "openness" present

1120-448: A successful proposition is placed directly on the ballot to be subject to vote (as exemplified by California's system). With an indirect initiative, a successful proposition is first presented to the legislature for their consideration; however, if no acceptable action is taken after a designated period of time, the proposition moves to direct popular vote. Constitutional amendments in Switzerland , Liechtenstein or Uruguay goes through such

1190-459: A valuable experience-base with the national-level constitutional amendment initiative. In the past 120 years, more than 240 initiatives have been put to referendums. Most popular initiatives are discussed and approved by the Parliament before the referendum. Out of the remaining initiatives that go to the referendum, only about 10% are approved by voters; in addition, voters often opt for a version of

1260-562: Is fundamentally complemented by its federal governmental structures (in German also called the Subsidiaritätsprinzip ). Most western countries have representative systems. Switzerland is a rare example of a country with instruments of direct democracy (at the levels of the municipalities, cantons , and federal state ). Citizens have more power than in a representative democracy. On any political level citizens can propose changes to

1330-575: Is said to be the Athenian democracy of the 5th century BC. The main bodies in the Athenian democracy were the assembly , composed of male citizens; the boulê , composed of 500 citizens; and the law courts, composed of a massive number of jurors chosen by lot, with no judges. Ancient Attica had only about 30,000 male citizens, but several thousand of them were politically active in each year and many of them quite regularly for years on end. The Athenian democracy

1400-410: Is the most common form of direct legislation. A popular referendum empowers citizens to make a petition that calls existing legislation to a vote by the citizens. Institutions specify the timeframe for a valid petition and the number of signatures required and may require signatures from diverse communities to protect minority interests. This form of direct democracy effectively grants the voting public

1470-478: Is the third and current federal constitution of Switzerland . It establishes the Swiss Confederation as a federal republic of 26 cantons (states). The document contains a catalogue of individual and popular rights (including the right to call for popular referendums on federal laws and constitutional amendments ), delineates the responsibilities of the cantons and the Confederation and establishes

SECTION 20

#1732858856025

1540-554: The constitution , but at least 1,500 citizens must vote affirmative, so referendums to suspend parliament or change the constitution fail if they have low turnout even if the required percentage of total voters is met. The pure form of direct democracy exists only in the Swiss cantons of Appenzell Innerrhoden and Glarus . The Swiss Confederation is a semi-direct democracy (representative democracy with strong instruments of direct democracy). The nature of direct democracy in Switzerland

1610-579: The free software movement to the governance of people, allowing the entire populace to participate in government directly, as much or as little as they please. Athenian democracy developed in the Greek city-state of Athens , comprising the city of Athens and the surrounding territory of Attica , around 600 BC. Athens was one of the first known democracies . Other Greek cities set up democracies, and even though most followed an Athenian model, none were as powerful, stable, or well-documented as that of Athens. In

1680-481: The liberal democratic standpoint, restraining popular influence stonewalls the state of nature , protecting property rights . Adversaries of greater democratization cast doubt on human nature , painting a narrative of misinformation and impulsivity. MAREZ , utilizing sortition , had managed itself successfully prior to being overrun by drug cartels, as did FEJUVE remaining tranquil with self-managed organizations. Although Revolutionary Catalonia had demonstrated

1750-520: The 23 members were not involved and that police arrested anyone they could find connected to the Backyarder movement. The case was dismissed due to lack of evidence. The Backyarders have become increasingly critical of voting whose purpose they see as providing legitimacy to corrupt politicians despite little change in their condition. They have become fed-up with the voting process which they see as an undemocratic ritual and have threatened not to vote in

1820-574: The Constitution's bill of rights and consists of 35 articles. The 1874 constitution contained only a limited number of fundamental rights , and some of them grew less significant as the 20th century wore on, such as the right to a decent burial guaranteed in article 53 of the old constitution. In consequence, the Swiss Federal Supreme Court 's extensive case law developed an array of implicit or "unwritten" fundamental rights, drawing upon

1890-679: The ECHR, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights . Title 2 also covers the essential rules on the acquisition of Swiss citizenship and of the exercise of political rights. Furthermore, it contains a number of not directly enforceable "social goals" which the state shall strive to ensure, including the availability of social security , health care and housing . Title 2 refers to Swiss people as "women and men of Switzerland" as

1960-457: The Federal Court. It also provides for greater details in tax laws. The Constitution of 1999 has been changed by popular initiative ten times in the period of 2002 to 2014, as follows: The preamble and the first title of the Constitution determine the general outlines of Switzerland as a democratic federal republic of 26 cantons governed by the rule of law . The preamble opens with

2030-478: The New York Ratifying Convention, Alexander Hamilton was quoted saying "that a pure democracy, if it were practicable, would be the most perfect government. Experience has proved that no position is falser than this. The ancient democracies in which the people themselves deliberated never possessed one good feature of government. Their very character was tyranny; their figure, deformity." Despite

2100-602: The Provincial Housing Department towards organising a probe into the illegal buying and selling of RDP houses in the area. Backyarder protests have also forced provincial government to fire corrupt contractors from Mandela Park developments. In September 2009, Mandela Park Backyarders protested against what they called a false promise of 23 houses from MEC for Human Settlements Bonginkosi Madikizela. Twenty three backyarders were then arrested for allegedly vandalising government property. However, Backyarders claim that

2170-521: The Roman kingdom until after the collapse of the Western Roman Empire in 476 AD, it did not embody a purely democratic approach, being made up – during the late republic – of former elected officials, providing advice rather than creating law. The democratic aspect of the constitution resided in the Roman popular assemblies , where the people organized into centuriae or into tribes – depending on

Mandela Park Backyarders - Misplaced Pages Continue

2240-423: The Swiss electorate and cantons, on cantonal/communal levels often any financial decision of a certain substantial amount decreed by legislative and/or executive bodies as well. Swiss citizens vote regularly on any kind of issue on every political level, such as financial approvals of a schoolhouse or the building of a new street, or the change of the policy regarding sexual work, or on constitutional changes, or on

2310-530: The United States, towns in states such as Vermont decide local affairs through the direct democratic process of the town meeting . This is the oldest form of direct democracy in the United States and predates the founding of the country by at least a century. Direct democracy was not what the framers of the United States Constitution envisioned for the nation. They saw a danger in tyranny of

2380-515: The aspects about environment and spatial planning, public construction works and transport, energy and communications, economy in general, concerns about housing, employment, social security and health, about the rights of residence and settlement of foreign nationals, and finally about the responsibility regarding the civil and criminal law, weights and measures. The third chapter clarifies general financial aspects, in particular taxation. Title 4 clarifies fundamental political rights and in particular

2450-573: The assembly – and cast votes on various matters, including elections and laws, proposed before them by their elected magistrates. Some classicists have argued that the Roman republic deserves the label of "democracy", with universal suffrage for adult male citizens, popular sovereignty, and transparent deliberation of public affairs. Many historians mark the end of the Republic with the lex Titia , passed on 27 November 43 BC, which eliminated many oversight provisions. Modern-era citizen-lawmaking occurs in

2520-631: The basis of the current-day cantonal constitutions. Vaud introduced the legislative popular initiative in 1846. Berne introduced the legislative optional referendum in the same year. The political crisis of the Regeneration period culminated in the Sonderbund War of November 1847. As a result of the Sonderbund War, Switzerland was transformed into a federal state , with a constitution promulgated on 12 September 1848. This constitution provided for

2590-530: The brother of the tyrant Hippias , was killed by Harmodius and Aristogeiton , who were subsequently honored by the Athenians for their alleged restoration of Athenian freedom. The greatest and longest-lasting democratic leader was Pericles ; after his death, Athenian democracy was twice briefly interrupted by an oligarchic revolution towards the end of the Peloponnesian War . It was modified somewhat after it

2660-407: The cantons of Switzerland from the 13th century. In 1848 the Swiss added the "statute referendum" to their national constitution, requiring the public to vote on if a constitutional change should occur. They soon discovered that merely having the power to veto Parliament's laws was not enough. In 1891 they added the "constitutional amendment initiative". Swiss politics since 1891 have given the world

2730-572: The cantons' sovereignty, as long as this did not impinge on the Federal Constitution. The creation of a bicameral assembly was consciously inspired by the United States Constitution , the National Council and Council of States corresponding to the House of Representatives and Senate , respectively. In a partial revision of 1891, the " right of initiative " was introduced, under which

2800-581: The case law of the European Court of Human Rights and applying the fundamental rights guaranteed in the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which Switzerland ratified in 1974. In the course of the 1999 constitutional revision, the Federal Assembly decided to codify that case law in the form of a comprehensive bill of rights, which is substantially congruent with the rights guaranteed in

2870-670: The citizen lawmaking was in Pacific States Telephone and Telegraph Company v. Oregon , 223 U.S. 118 in 1912 (Zimmerman, December 1999). President Theodore Roosevelt , in his "Charter of Democracy" speech to the Ohio Constitutional Convention (1912) , stated: "I believe in the Initiative and Referendum, which should be used not to destroy representative government, but to correct it whenever it becomes misrepresentative." In various states, referendums through which

Mandela Park Backyarders - Misplaced Pages Continue

2940-427: The constituent cantons, affirm cantonal sovereignty within the bounds of the Constitution and list the national languages – German , French , Italian and Romansh . They also commit the state to the principles of obedience to law, proportionality , good faith and respect for international law , an explicit claim for subsidiarity , before closing with a reference to individual responsibility . Title 2 contains

3010-405: The constitution ( popular initiative ) or ask for an optional referendum to be held on any law voted by the federal , cantonal parliament and/or municipal legislative body. The list for mandatory or optional referendums on each political level are generally much longer in Switzerland than in any other country; for example, any amendment to the constitution must automatically be voted on by

3080-504: The constitutions of the new cantons of St. Gallen , Aargau , Thurgau , Ticino , Vaud and Geneva . The new cantonal constitutions in many cases served as precedents for the later federal constitution. Following the French July Revolution in 1830, a number of large assemblies were held calling for new cantonal constitutions. The modifications to the cantonal constitutions made during this period of " Regeneration " remains

3150-403: The core of the work of many theorists, philosophers, politicians, and social critics, among whom the most important are Jean-Jacques Rousseau , John Stuart Mill , and G.D.H. Cole . In direct democracy the people decide on policies without any intermediary or representative, whereas in a representative democracy people vote for representatives who then enact policy initiatives. Depending on

3220-537: The democratic process. Also relevant to the history of direct democracy is the history of Ancient Rome , specifically during the Roman Republic , traditionally founded around 509 BC. Rome displayed many aspects of democracy, both direct and indirect, from the era of Roman monarchy all the way to the collapse of the Roman Empire . While the Roman senate was the main body with historical longevity, lasting from

3290-409: The development of Athenian democracy. Historians differ on which of them was responsible for which institution, and which of them most represented a truly democratic movement. It is most usual to date Athenian democracy from Cleisthenes since Solon's constitution fell and was replaced by the tyranny of Peisistratus , whereas Ephialtes revised Cleisthenes' constitution relatively peacefully. Hipparchus ,

3360-458: The direct democracy of Athens, the citizens did not nominate representatives to vote on legislation and executive bills on their behalf (as in the United States) but instead voted as individuals. The public opinion of voters was influenced by the political satire of the comic poets in the theatres . Solon (594 BC), Cleisthenes (508–507 BCE), and Ephialtes (462 BC) all contributed to

3430-711: The feasibility of non-liberal democracy, critics have continued to deride its presumed mobocratic nature, although there are no recorded instances of tyranny of the majority . It is of note that direct democracy's critics have emerged from Hobbesian and liberal philosophy. Swiss Federal Constitution The Federal Constitution of the Swiss Confederation ( SR 10 ; German : Bundesverfassung der Schweizerischen Eidgenossenschaft ( BV ); French : Constitution fédérale de la Confédération suisse ( Cst. ); Italian : Costituzione federale della Confederazione Svizzera ( Cost. ); Romansh : Constituziun federala da la Confederaziun svizra ) of 18 April 1999 ( SR 101 )

3500-475: The federal authorities of government. The Constitution was adopted by a referendum on 18 April 1999 , in which a majority of the people and the cantons voted in favour. It replaced the prior federal constitution of 1874, which it was intended to bring up to date without changing its substance. Prior to 1798, the Swiss Confederacy was a confederation of independent states, not a federal state; as such it

3570-492: The foreign policy of Switzerland, four times a year. Between January 1995 and June 2005, Swiss citizens voted 31 times, on 103 federal questions besides many more cantonal and municipal questions. During the same period, French citizens participated in only two referendums. In Switzerland , simple majorities are sufficient at the municipal and cantonal level, at the federal level double majorities are required on constitutional issues. A double majority requires approval by

SECTION 50

#1732858856025

3640-430: The framers' intentions at the beginning of the republic, ballot measures and their corresponding referendums have been widely used at the state and sub-state level. There is much state and federal case law , from the early 1900s to the 1990s, that protects the people's right to each of these direct democracy governance components (Magleby, 1984, and Zimmerman, 1999). The first United States Supreme Court ruling in favor of

3710-465: The initiative rewritten by the government. (See "Direct democracy in Switzerland" below.) Some of the issues surrounding the related notion of a direct democracy using the Internet and other communications technologies are dealt with in the article on e-democracy and below under the heading Electronic direct democracy . More concisely, the concept of open-source governance applies principles of

3780-543: The majority . As a result, they advocated a representative democracy in the form of a constitutional republic over a direct democracy. For example, James Madison , in Federalist No. 10 , advocates a constitutional republic over direct democracy precisely to protect the individual from the will of the majority. He says, Those who hold and those who are without property have ever formed distinct interests in society. Those who are creditors, and those who are debtors, fall under

3850-481: The necessary and ordinary operations of the government. [...] [A] pure democracy, by which I mean a society consisting of a small number of citizens, who assemble and administer the government in person, can admit no cure for the mischiefs of faction. A common passion or interest will be felt by a majority, and there is nothing to check the inducements to sacrifice the weaker party. Hence it is, that democracies have ever been found incompatible with personal security or

3920-401: The particular system in use, direct democracy might entail passing executive decisions, the use of sortition , making laws , directly electing or dismissing officials, and conducting trials . Two leading forms of direct democracy are participatory democracy and deliberative democracy . Semi-direct democracies, in which representatives administer day-to-day governance, but the citizens remain

3990-532: The people rule include: The strength of direct democracy in individual countries can be quantitatively compared by the Citizen-initiated component of direct popular vote index in V-Dem Democracy indices . A higher index indicates more direct democracy popular initiatives and referendums, shown below for individual countries. Only countries with index above 0 are shown. Democratic theorists have identified

4060-451: The population on whose behalf decisions are taken have an equal chance of having their views taken into account. Empirical evidence from dozens of studies suggests deliberation leads to better decision making. The most popularly disputed form of direct popular participation is the referendum on constitutional matters. For the system to respect the principle of political equality, either everyone needs to be involved or there needs to be

4130-480: The prohibition of absinthe . Title 3 describes in the first chapter the relationships between the Confederation, the cantons and the communes. The cantons retain their own constitutions, but in the case of contradiction the Federal Constitution prevails. The second chapter declares the federal power about areas that require uniform regulation, such as relations with foreign states, security, national and civil defence, general aspects about education, research, culture,

4200-708: The rights for initiatives and referendums . Title 5 regulates the function and responsibilities of the Federal Government. It provides for three branches of the government represented by three bodies: the Federal Assembly (two chambers, representing the Legislative power), Federal Council (the Executive power), and the Federal Court (the Judicial power). The main differences compared to the previous constitution deal with

4270-458: The rights of property; and have, in general, been as short in their lives as they have been violent in their deaths. Other framers spoke against pure democracy. John Witherspoon , one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence , said: "Pure democracy cannot subsist long nor be carried far into the departments of state – it is very subject to caprice and the madness of popular rage." At

SECTION 60

#1732858856025

4340-412: The sovereign, allow for three forms of popular action: referendum (plebiscite), initiative , and recall . The first two forms—referendums and initiatives—are examples of direct legislation. As of 2019 , thirty countries allowed for referendums initiated by the population on the national level. A compulsory referendum subjects the legislation drafted by political elites to a binding popular vote. This

4410-480: The term to stress, inter alia , the plebiscitary character of elections, disdain for parliament, the non-toleration of autonomous powers within the government and a failure to attract or suffer independent political minds." Despite being a monarchy, direct democracy is considered to be an engrained element of Liechtensteiner politics . If called for by at least 1,000 citizens, a referendum on any law can be initiated. Referendums can suspend parliament or change

4480-537: The upcoming elections. The Bhumi Uchhed Pratirodh Committee in India Direct democracy Direct democracy or pure democracy is a form of democracy in which the electorate decides on policy initiatives without elected representatives as proxies. This differs from the majority of currently established democracies, which are representative democracies . The theory and practice of direct democracy and participation as its common characteristic constituted

4550-479: The votes of students and staff are weighted equally. The core criticism of direct democracy coincides with democracy's overall criticism. Critics have historically expressed doubts of the populace's capacity of participation, deeming its advocates utopian. Despite this, instances of direct democracy - such as the Petrograd Soviet - lack documented incidents involving participation deficits or mobocracy . From

4620-413: Was direct not only in the sense that the assembled people made decisions, but also in the sense that the people – through the assembly, boulê, and law courts – controlled the entire political process, and a large proportion of citizens were involved constantly in public affairs. Most modern democracies, being representative, not direct, do not resemble the Athenian system. Moreover, the Athenian democracy

4690-666: Was based on treaties rather than a constitution. The Helvetic Republic of 1798–1803 had a constitution largely drawn up by Peter Ochs , in 1803 replaced by the Act of Mediation , which was in turn replaced by the Federal Treaty of 1815, which restored the Confederacy, while the individual cantons drew up cantonal constitutions, in most respects based on the Ancien Régime of the 18th century , but with notable liberal innovations in

4760-469: Was exclusive. For example, in Athens in the middle of the 4th century there were about 100,000 citizens (Athenian citizenship was limited to men and women whose parents had also been Athenian citizens), about 10,000 metoikoi, or “resident foreigners,” and 150,000 slaves. Out of all those people, only male citizens who were older than 18 were a part of the demos, meaning only about 40,000 people could participate in

4830-551: Was restored under Eucleides ; the most detailed accounts are of this 4th-century modification rather than of the Periclean system. It was suppressed by the Macedonians in 322 BC. The Athenian institutions were later revived, but the extent to which they were a real democracy is debatable. Sociologist Max Weber believed that every mass democracy went in a Caesarist direction. Professor of law Gerhard Casper writes, "Weber employed

4900-408: Was wholly revised for the second time in the 1990s, when the new version was approved by popular and cantonal vote on 18 April 1999. It came into force on 1 January 2000. The 1999 Constitution of Switzerland consists of a preamble and six parts, which together make up 196 articles. It provides an explicit provision for nine fundamental rights, which up until then had only been discussed and debated in

#24975