Misplaced Pages

#742257

85-982: For decades, the journal, which was founded in 1964, was the only one to publish articles from all schools of psychoanalysis, including interpersonal, relational, Freudian, Jungian, and Object Relations. It also publishes empirical research about human development and unconscious process. The current editors-in-chief are Ruth Livingston and Susan Fabrick . The journal has featured articles on interpersonal processes and intersubjectivity by authors such as Stephen Mitchell , Harold Searles , Edgar Levenson, Benjamin Wolstein, Joyce McDougall, Philip Bromberg , Irwin Hoffman, Jessica Benjamin , Silvano Arieti , Darlene Ehrenberg, Donnel Stern, and James Grotstein. It has published articles on psychoanalytic perspectives on prejudice due to race, sexuality, and religion. There have been discussions of contemporary psychodynamic approaches to depression from

170-592: A M.A. thesis) from the University of Paris , on the basis of the (now-lost) thesis La Notion de multiple intelligible chez Plotin (" Plotinus 's Notion of the Intelligible Many"), directed by Émile Bréhier . He passed the agrégation in philosophy in 1930. Merleau-Ponty was raised as a Roman Catholic . He was friends with the Christian existentialist author and philosopher Gabriel Marcel and wrote articles for

255-586: A balanced view between personal and universal views of our social cognition. This approach suggests that, instead of being individual or universal thinkers, human beings subscribe to "thought communities"—communities of differing beliefs. Thought community examples include churches, professions, scientific beliefs, generations, nations, and political movements. This perspective explains why each individual thinks differently from another (individualism): person A may choose to adhere to expiry dates on foods, but person B may believe that expiry dates are only guidelines and it

340-635: A daily basis. Having grown up within this context may have led to members of this community to have what is described by some as a "blending of agendas", or by others as a "dovetailing of motives". If community or family members have the same general goals in mind they may thus act cohesively within an overlapping state of mind. Whether persons are in each other's presence or merely within the same community this blending of agendas or dovetailing of motives enables intersubjectivity to occur within these shared endeavors. The cultural value of respeto may also contribute to intersubjectivity in some communities; unlike

425-479: A dimension of expressivity which proves to be fundamental to the constitution of the ego is one of the conclusions of The Structure of Behaviour that is constantly reiterated in Merleau-Ponty's later works. Following this theme of expressivity, he goes on to examine how an incarnate subject is in a position to undertake actions that transcend the organic level of the body, such as in intellectual operations and

510-625: A dog, both the owner's behavior is regulated by the dog stopping and sniffing, and the dog's behavior is regulated by the lead and the owner's commands. Ergo, walking the dog is an example of an interactive process. For Gallagher, interaction and direct perception constitute what he terms "primary" (or basic) intersubjectivity. Studies of dialogue and dialogism reveal how language is deeply intersubjective. When we speak, we always address our interlocutors, taking their perspective and orienting to what we think they think (or, more often, don't think). Within this tradition of research, it has been argued that

595-425: A higher level of analysis. Thus, Merleau-Ponty does not postulate that "all consciousness is consciousness of something", which supposes at the outset a noetic-noematic ground. Instead, he develops the thesis according to which "all consciousness is perceptual consciousness". In doing so, he establishes a significant turn in the development of phenomenology, indicating that its conceptualisations should be re-examined in

680-430: A model and "putting ourselves in another's shoes"—that is, by imagining what our mental states would be and how we would behave if we were in the other's situation. More specifically, we simulate what the other's mental states could have been to cause the observed behaviour, then use the simulated mental states, pretend beliefs, and pretend desires as input, running them through our own decision-making mechanism. We then take

765-638: A more favourable attitude towards Soviet communism . Merleau-Ponty was subsequently active in the French non-communist left and in particular in the Union of the Democratic Forces . Merleau-Ponty died suddenly of a stroke in 1961 at age 53, apparently while preparing for a class on René Descartes , leaving an unfinished manuscript which was posthumously published in 1964, along with a selection of Merleau-Ponty's working notes, by Claude Lefort as The Visible and

850-426: A new Gestalt oriented toward a particular object. Because the bodily involvement with things is always provisional and indeterminate, meaningful things are encountered in a unified though ever open-ended world. From the time of writing Structure of Behaviour and Phenomenology of Perception , Merleau-Ponty wanted to show, in opposition to the idea that drove the tradition beginning with John Locke , that perception

935-439: A rereading of Merleau-Ponty's influence on Simone de Beauvoir. (She has also challenged Dreyfus's reading of Merleau-Ponty as behaviorist , and as neglecting the importance of the phenomenological reduction to Merleau-Ponty's thought.) Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology of the body has also been taken up by Iris Young in her essay " Throwing Like a Girl ," and its follow-up, "'Throwing Like a Girl': Twenty Years Later". Young analyzes

SECTION 10

#1732863091743

1020-465: A shared culture. The bidirectional aspect lets the active parties organize the relationship how they see fit—what they see as important receives the most focus. Emphasis is placed on the idea that children are actively involved in how they learn, using intersubjectivity. The ways intersubjectivity occurs varies across cultures. In certain Indigenous American communities, nonverbal communication

1105-668: A social domain." Psychoanalyst Molly Macdonald argued in 2011 that a "potential point of origin" for the term was in Jean Hyppolite 's use of l'inter-subjectivité in an essay from 1955 on "The Human Situation in the Hegelian Phenomenology". However, the phenomenologist Edmund Husserl , whose work Habermas and Hyppolite draw upon, was the first to develop the term, which was subsequently elaborated upon by other phenomenologists such as Edith Stein , Emmanuel Levinas , and Maurice Merleau-Ponty . Contemporarily, intersubjectivity

1190-436: A target's behaviour what his or her mental states probably are. And from these inferences, plus the psychological principles in the theory connecting mental states to behavior, we predict the target's behaviour (Carruthers and Smith 1996; Davies and Stone 1995a; Gopnik and Wellman 1992; Nichols and Stich 2003). Simulation theorists , on the other hand, claim that we explain and predict others' behaviour by using our own minds as

1275-548: Is "all consciousness is consciousness of something", which implies a distinction between "acts of thought" (the noesis ) and "intentional objects of thought" (the noema ). Thus, the correlation between noesis and noema becomes the first step in the constitution of analyses of consciousness. However, in studying the posthumous manuscripts of Husserl, who remained one of his major influences, Merleau-Ponty remarked that, in their evolution, Husserl's work brings to light phenomena which are not assimilable to noesis–noema correlation. This

1360-645: Is anti-individualistic. In the preface to his Phenomenology of Perception , Merleau-Ponty presents a phenomenological objection to positivism : that it can reveal nothing about human subjectivity. All that a scientific text can explain is the particular individual experience of that scientist, which cannot be transcended. For Merleau-Ponty, science neglects the depth and profundity of the phenomena that it endeavors to explain. Merleau-Ponty understood science to be an ex post facto abstraction. Causal and physiological accounts of perception, for example, explain perception in terms that are arrived at only after abstracting from

1445-452: Is born of the pre-conscious style of the world, of Nature. In his essay Cézanne's Doubt , in which he identifies Paul Cézanne 's impressionistic theory of painting as analogous to his own concept of radical reflection, the attempt to return to, and reflect on, prereflective consciousness, Merleau-Ponty identifies science as the opposite of art. In Merleau-Ponty's account, whereas art is an attempt to capture an individual's perception, science

1530-442: Is intersubjectivity between people if they agree on a given set of meanings or share the same perception of a situation. Similarly, Thomas Scheff defines intersubjectivity as "the sharing of subjective states by two or more individuals". Intersubjectivity also has been used to refer to the common-sense , shared meanings constructed by people in their interactions with each other and used as an everyday resource to interpret

1615-520: Is just political action to be decided? Merleau-Ponty maintained an engaged though critical relationship to the Marxist left until the end of his life, particularly during his time as the political editor of the journal Les Temps modernes . Maurice Merleau-Ponty was born in 1908 in Rochefort-sur-Mer , Charente-Inférieure (now Charente-Maritime), France . His father died in 1913 when Merleau-Ponty

1700-414: Is manifest precisely by presenting itself to a range of possible views. The object of perception is immanently tied to its background—to the nexus of meaningful relations among objects within the world. Because the object is inextricably within the world of meaningful relations, each object reflects the other (much in the style of Leibniz's monads ). Through involvement in the world – being-in-the-world –

1785-415: Is not nature or the biosphere conceived as a complex set of objects and objective processes, but rather "the biosphere as it is experienced and lived from within by the intelligent body — by the attentive human animal who is entirely a part of the world that he or she experiences. Merleau-Ponty's ecophenemonology with its emphasis on holistic dialog within the larger-than-human world also has implications for

SECTION 20

#1732863091743

1870-544: Is particularly the case when one attends to the phenomena of the body (which is at once body-subject and body-object), subjective time (the consciousness of time is neither an act of consciousness nor an object of thought) and the other (the first considerations of the other in Husserl led to solipsism ). The distinction between "acts of thought" (noesis) and " intentional objects of thought" (noema) does not seem, therefore, to constitute an irreducible ground. It appears rather at

1955-638: Is situated in a kind of middle ground of relationality, a space that is neither purely objective, because it is reciprocally constituted by a diversity of lived experiences motivating the movements of countless organisms, nor purely subjective, because it is nonetheless a field of material relationships between bodies. It is governed exclusively neither by causality, nor by intentionality. In this space of in-betweenness, phenomenology can overcome its inaugural opposition to naturalism. David Abram explains Merleau-Ponty's concept of "flesh" ( chair ) as "the mysterious tissue or matrix that underlies and gives rise to both

2040-524: Is so prevalent that intersubjectivity may occur regularly amongst all members of the community, in part perhaps due to a "joint cultural understanding" and a history of shared endeavors. This "joint cultural understanding" may develop in small, Indigenous American communities where children have grown up embedded in their community's values, expectations, and livelihoods—learning through participation with adults rather than through intent verbal instruction—working in cohesion with one another in shared endeavors on

2125-449: Is still safe to eat the food days past the expiry date. But not all human beings think the same way (universalism). Intersubjectivity argues that each thought community shares social experiences that are different from the social experiences of other thought communities, creating differing beliefs among people who subscribe to different thought communities. These experiences transcend our subjectivity, which explains why they can be shared by

2210-401: Is taking place in social cognition research, away from a focus on the individual mind and toward ... participatory aspects of social understanding...." Interaction theory is put forward to "galvanize" the interactive turn in explanations of intersubjectivity. Gallagher defines an interaction as two or more autonomous agents engaged in co-regulated coupling behavior. For example, when walking

2295-620: Is the relation or intersection between people's cognitive perspectives . Intersubjectivity is a term coined by social scientists beginning around 1970 to refer to a variety of types of human interaction. The term was introduced to psychoanalysis by George E. Atwood and Robert Stolorow , who consider it a "meta-theory" of psychoanalysis. For example, social psychologists Alex Gillespie and Flora Cornish listed at least seven definitions of intersubjectivity (and other disciplines have additional definitions): Intersubjectivity has been used in social science to refer to agreement. There

2380-456: Is the major topic in both the analytic and the continental traditions of philosophy. Intersubjectivity is considered crucial not only at the relational level but also at the epistemological and even metaphysical levels. For example, intersubjectivity is postulated as playing a role in establishing the truth of propositions, and constituting the intersubjective agreement of an experience of an object. A central concern in consciousness studies of

2465-444: Is these uses of the notion of style that lead Malraux to postulate a cleavage between the objectivity of Italian Renaissance painting and the subjectivity of painting in his own time, a conclusion that Merleau-Ponty disputes. According to Merleau-Ponty, it is important to consider the heart of this problematic, by recognizing that style is first of all a demand owed to the primacy of perception, which also implies taking into consideration

2550-502: Is used, on the contrary, in a very metaphysical sense (in Merleau-Ponty's opinion, a mystical sense), in which style is connected with a conception of an "über-artist" expressing "the Spirit of Painting". Finally, it sometimes is reduced to simply designating a categorization of an artistic school or movement. (However, this account of Malraux's notion of style—a key element in his thinking—is open to serious question. ) For Merleau-Ponty, it

2635-653: The Christian leftist journal Esprit , but he left the Catholic Church in 1937 because he felt his socialist politics were not compatible with the social and political doctrine of the Catholic Church. An article published in the French newspaper Le Monde in October 2014 makes the case of recent discoveries about Merleau-Ponty's likely authorship of the novel Nord. Récit de l'arctique (Grasset, 1928). Convergent sources from close friends (Beauvoir, Elisabeth "Zaza" Lacoin) seem to leave little doubt that Jacques Heller

Contemporary Psychoanalysis - Misplaced Pages Continue

2720-676: The Invisible . He is buried in Père Lachaise Cemetery in Paris with his mother Louise, his wife Suzanne and their daughter Marianne. In his Phenomenology of Perception (first published in French in 1945), Merleau-Ponty develops the concept of the body-subject ( le corps propre ) as an alternative to the Cartesian " cogito ". This distinction is especially important in that Merleau-Ponty perceives

2805-605: The Nazi forces during the liberation of Paris . After teaching at the University of Lyon from 1945 to 1948, Merleau-Ponty lectured on child psychology and education at the Sorbonne from 1949 to 1952. He was awarded the Chair of Philosophy at the Collège de France from 1952 until his death in 1961, making him the youngest person to have been elected to a chair. Besides his teaching, Merleau-Ponty

2890-599: The Soviet farce trials and political violence for progressive ends in general in the work Humanism and Terror in 1947. Kuby states that, about three years after that, however, he renounced his earlier support for political violence, rejected Marxism, and advocated a liberal left position in Adventures of the Dialectic (1955). His friendship with Sartre and work with Les Temps modernes ended because of that, since Sartre still had

2975-521: The Soviet farce trials . Slavoj Zizek opines that it avoids the definitive endorsement of a view on the Soviet Union , but instead engages with the Marxist theory of history as a critique of liberalism , in order to reveal an unresolved antinomy in modern politics, between humanism and terror : if human values can only be achieved through violent force, and if liberal ideas hide illiberal realities, how

3060-407: The essences of the world existentially . Consciousness , the world, and the human body as a perceiving thing are intricately intertwined and mutually "engaged". The phenomenal thing is not the unchanging object of the natural sciences , but a correlate of the human body and its sensory-motor functions. Taking up and "communing with" (Merleau-Ponty's phrase) the sensible qualities it encounters,

3145-413: The "I can" – that is, oriented towards certain projects based on capacity and habituality. Young's thesis is that in women, this intentionality is inhibited and ambivalent, rather than confident, experienced as an "I cannot". Ecophenomenology can be described as the pursuit of the relationalities of worldly engagement, both human and those of other creatures (Brown & Toadvine 2003). This engagement

3230-562: The Andean mountains learned to weave without explicit instruction. They learned the basic technique from others by observing, eager to participate in their community. The learning process was facilitated by watching adults and by being allowed to play and experiment using tools to create their own weaving techniques. Maurice Merleau-Ponty Maurice Jean Jacques Merleau-Ponty ( / ˈ m ɜːr l oʊ ˈ p ɒ n t i / ; French: [moʁis mɛʁlo pɔ̃ti] ; 14 March 1908 – 3 May 1961)

3315-634: The English definition of 'respect', respeto refers loosely to a mutual consideration for others' activities, needs, wants, etc. Similar to "putting yourself in another's shoes" the prevalence of respeto in certain Indigenous American communities in Mexico and South America may promote intersubjectivity as persons act in accordance with one another within consideration for the community or the individual's current needs or state of mind. Shared reference during an activity facilitates learning. Adults either teach by doing

3400-514: The Voices of Silence". In spite of certain similarities with André Malraux , Merleau-Ponty distinguishes himself from Malraux in respect to three conceptions of style, the last of which is employed in Malraux's The Voices of Silence . Merleau-Ponty remarks that in this work "style" is sometimes used by Malraux in a highly subjective sense, understood as a projection of the artist's individuality. Sometimes it

3485-451: The World , p. 10). Spoken language ( le langage parlé ), or secondary expression, returns to the speaker's linguistic baggage and cultural heritage, as well as the brute mass of relationships between signs and significations . Speaking language ( le langage parlant ), or primary expression, such as it is, is language in the production of a sense, language at the advent of a thought, at

Contemporary Psychoanalysis - Misplaced Pages Continue

3570-422: The body as incarnated subjectivity intentionally elaborates things within an ever-present world frame, through use of its pre-conscious, pre-predicative understanding of the world's makeup. The elaboration, however, is "inexhaustible" (the hallmark of any perception according to Merleau-Ponty). Things are that upon which the body has a "grip" ( prise ), while the grip itself is a function of human connaturality with

3655-427: The body's primordial involvement and understanding of the world and of the meanings that constitute the landscape's perceptual Gestalt . Only after an integration within the environment so as to perceive objects as such can attention be turned toward particular objects within the landscape so as to define them more clearly. This attention, however, does not operate by clarifying what is already seen, but by constructing

3740-424: The core of Merleau-Ponty's philosophy is a sustained argument for the foundational role that perception plays in the human experience of the world . Merleau-Ponty understands perception to be an ongoing dialogue between one's lived body and the world which it perceives, in which perceivers passively and actively strive to express the perceived world in concert with others. He was the only major phenomenologist of

3825-406: The development of his thought. As the course outlines of his Sorbonne lectures indicate, during this period he continues a dialogue between phenomenology and the diverse work carried out in psychology , all in order to return to the study of the acquisition of language in children, as well as to broadly take advantage of the contribution of Ferdinand de Saussure to linguistics , and to work on

3910-405: The dimensions of historicity and intersubjectivity . (However, Merleau-Ponty's reading of Malraux has been questioned in a recent major study of Malraux's theory of art which argues that Merleau-Ponty seriously misunderstood Malraux.) For Merleau-Ponty, style is born of the interaction between two or more fields of being. Rather than being exclusive to individual human consciousness, consciousness

3995-638: The dualist ontology of mind and body in Descartes, a philosopher to whom Merleau-Ponty continually returned, despite the important differences that separate them. In the Phenomenology of Perception Merleau-Ponty wrote: "Insofar as I have hands, feet, a body, I sustain around me intentions which are not dependent on my decisions and which affect my surroundings in a way that I do not choose" (1962, p. 440). The question concerning corporeity connects also with Merleau-Ponty's reflections on space ( l'espace ) and

4080-431: The entire thought community. Proponents of intersubjectivity support the view that individual beliefs are often the result of thought community beliefs, not just personal experiences or universal and objective human beliefs. Beliefs are recast in terms of standards, which are set by thought communities. Edmund Husserl , the founder of phenomenology , recognized the importance of intersubjectivity, and wrote extensively on

4165-401: The fact that there is an inherence of consciousness and of the body of which the analysis of perception should take account. The primacy of perception signifies a primacy of experience, so to speak, insofar as perception becomes an active and constitutive dimension. Merleau-Ponty demonstrates a corporeity of consciousness as much as an intentionality of the body, and so stands in contrast with

4250-435: The first half of the twentieth century to engage extensively with the sciences. It is through this engagement that his writings became influential in the project of naturalising phenomenology, in which phenomenologists use the results of psychology and cognitive science . Merleau-Ponty emphasised the body as the primary site of knowing the world, a corrective to the long philosophical tradition of placing consciousness as

4335-432: The light of the primacy of perception, in weighing up the philosophical consequences of this thesis. Taking the study of perception as his point of departure, Merleau-Ponty was led to recognize that one's own body ( le corps propre ) is not only a thing, a potential object of study for science, but is also a permanent condition of experience , a constituent of the perceptual openness to the world. He therefore underlines

SECTION 50

#1732863091743

4420-458: The meaning of elements of social and cultural life. If people share common sense, then they share a definition of the situation. Psychoanalyst Jessica Benjamin, in The Bonds of Love , wrote, "The concept of intersubjectivity has its origins in the social theory of Jürgen Habermas (1970), who used the expression 'the intersubjectivity of mutual understanding' to designate an individual capacity and

4505-490: The moment where it makes itself an advent of sense. It is speaking language, that is to say, primary expression, that interests Merleau-Ponty and which keeps his attention through his treatment of the nature of production and the reception of expressions, a subject which also overlaps with an analysis of action, of intentionality, of perception, as well as the links between freedom and external conditions. The notion of style occupies an important place in "Indirect Language and

4590-407: The notion of structure through a discussion of work in psychology, linguistics and social anthropology . Merleau-Ponty distinguishes between primary and secondary modes of expression. This distinction appears in Phenomenology of Perception (p. 207, 2nd note [Fr. ed.]) and is sometimes repeated in terms of spoken and speaking language ( le langage parlé et le langage parlant ) ( The Prose of

4675-424: The ontogenesis and phylogenesis of language; indeed he states that "language is the very voice of the trees, the waves and the forest". Merleau-Ponty himself refers to "that primordial being which is not yet the subject-being nor the object-being and which in every respect baffles reflection. From this primordial being to us, there is no derivation, nor any break..." Among the many working notes found on his desk at

4760-414: The other side of humanity (as flesh, nowise as 'matter')." This resonates with the conception of space, place, dwelling, and embodiment (in the flesh and physical, vs. virtual and cybernetic), especially as they are addressed against the background of the unfolding of the essence of modern technology. Such analytics figure in a Heideggerian take on "econtology" as an extension of Heidegger's consideration of

4845-403: The particular modalities of feminine bodily comportment as they differ from that of men. Young observes that while a man who throws a ball puts his whole body into the motion, a woman throwing a ball generally restricts her own movements as she makes them, and that, generally, in sports, women move in a more tentative, reactive way. Merleau-Ponty argues that people experience the world in terms of

4930-601: The past 50 years is the so-called problem of other minds, which asks how we can justify our belief that people have minds much like our own and predict others' mind-states and behavior, as our experience shows we often can. Contemporary philosophical theories of intersubjectivity need to address the problem of other minds. In the debate between cognitive individualism and cognitive universalism, some aspects of thinking are neither solely personal nor fully universal. Cognitive sociology proponents argue for intersubjectivity —an intermediate perspective of social cognition that provides

5015-451: The perceiver and the perceived as interdependent aspects of its spontaneous activity", and he identifies this elemental matrix with the interdependent web of earthly life. This concept unites subject and object dialectically as determinations within a more primordial reality, which Merleau-Ponty calls "the flesh" and which Abram refers to variously as "the animate earth", "the breathing biosphere" or "the more-than-human natural world". Yet this

5100-435: The perceiver tacitly experiences all the perspectives upon that object coming from all the surrounding things of its environment, as well as the potential perspectives that that object has upon the beings around it. Each object is a "mirror of all others". The perception of the object through all perspectives is not that of a propositional, or clearly delineated, perception; rather, it is an ambiguous perception founded upon

5185-553: The perspective of the patient and clinician. The journal is owned by the William Alanson White Institute and Society. This article about an academic journal on psychology is a stub . You can help Misplaced Pages by expanding it . See tips for writing articles about academic journals . Further suggestions might be found on the article's talk page . Intersubjectivity In philosophy , psychology , sociology , and anthropology , intersubjectivity

SECTION 60

#1732863091743

5270-422: The phenomenon itself. Merleau-Ponty chastised science for taking itself to be the area in which a complete account of nature may be given. The subjective depth of phenomena cannot be given in science as it is. This characterizes Merleau-Ponty's attempt to ground science in phenomenological objectivity and, in essence, to institute a "return to the phenomena". Merleau-Ponty's critical position with respect to science

5355-407: The primacy of the dimension of depth ( la profondeur ) as implied in the notion of being in the world ( être au monde ; to echo Heidegger 's In-der-Welt-sein ) and of one's own body ( le corps propre ). Reflections on spatiality in phenomenology are also central to the advanced philosophical deliberations in architectural theory . The highlighting of the fact that corporeity intrinsically has

5440-435: The principles of chaos theory . It was through this relationship with Merleau-Ponty's work that cognitive science's affair with phenomenology was born, which is represented by a growing number of works, including Merleau-Ponty has also been picked up by Australian and Nordic philosophers inspired by the French feminist tradition, including Rosalyn Diprose and Sara Heinämaa  [ fi ] . Heinämaa has argued for

5525-900: The problem of intersubjectivity and puts forward his theory of transcendental, monadological intersubjectivity. Husserl's student Edith Stein extended intersubjectivity's basis in empathy in her 1917 doctoral dissertation, On the Problem of Empathy ( Zum Problem der Einfühlung ). Discussions and theories of intersubjectivity are prominent and of importance in contemporary psychology, theory of mind, and consciousness studies. Three major contemporary theories of intersubjectivity are theory theory, simulation theory, and interaction theory. Shannon Spaulding, Assistant Professor of Philosophy at Oklahoma State University , wrote: Theory theorists argue that we explain and predict behaviour by employing folk psychological theories about how mental states inform behaviour. With our folk psychological theories, we infer from

5610-467: The products of one's cultural life. He carefully considers language , then, as the core of culture , by examining in particular the connections between the unfolding of thought and sense—enriching his perspective not only by an analysis of the acquisition of language and the expressivity of the body, but also by taking into account pathologies of language, painting, cinema, literature, poetry, and music. This work deals mainly with language, beginning with

5695-442: The publication in 1991 of The Embodied Mind by Francisco Varela , Evan Thompson , and Eleanor Rosch , this association was extended, if only partially, to another strand of "anti-cognitivist" or post-representationalist cognitive science: embodied or enactive cognitive science, and later in the decade, to neurophenomenology . In addition, Merleau-Ponty's work has also influenced researchers trying to integrate neuroscience with

5780-642: The reflection on artistic expression in The Structure of Behavior —which contains a passage on El Greco (p. 203ff) that prefigures the remarks that he develops in "Cézanne's Doubt" (1945) and follows the discussion in Phenomenology of Perception . The work, undertaken while serving as the Chair of Child Psychology and Pedagogy at the University of the Sorbonne, is not a departure from his philosophical and phenomenological works, but rather an important continuation in

5865-540: The resulting conclusion and attribute it to the other person. Authors like Vittorio Gallese have proposed a theory of embodied simulation that refers to neuroscientific research on mirror neurons and phenomenological research. Spaulding noted that this debate has stalled in the past few years, with progress limited to articulating various hybrid simulation theories—"theory theory" accounts. To resolve this impasse, authors like Shaun Gallagher put forward interaction theory. Gallagher writes that an "... important shift

5950-600: The source of knowledge , and maintained that the perceiving body and its perceived world could not be disentangled from each other. The articulation of the primacy of embodiment ( corporéité ) led him away from phenomenology towards what he was to call "indirect ontology" or the ontology of "the flesh of the world" ( la chair du monde ), seen in his final and incomplete work, The Visible and Invisible , and his last published essay, "Eye and Mind". Merleau-Ponty engaged with Marxism throughout his career. His 1947 book, Humanism and Terror , has been widely understood as defense of

6035-447: The structure of individual signs or symbols, the basis of language, is intersubjective and that the psychological process of self-reflection entails intersubjectivity. Recent research on mirror neurons provides evidence for the deeply intersubjective basis of human psychology, and arguably much of the literature on empathy and theory of mind relates directly to intersubjectivity. Colwyn Trevarthen has applied intersubjectivity to

6120-548: The summer of 1939, as France declared war on Nazi Germany , he served on the frontlines in the French Army , where he was wounded in battle in June 1940. Upon returning to Paris in the fall of 1940, he married Suzanne Jolibois, a Lacanian psychoanalyst , and founded an underground resistance group with Jean-Paul Sartre called "Under the Boot". He participated in an armed demonstration against

6205-500: The task with children, or by directing attention toward experts. Children that had to ask questions in regard to how to perform a task were scolded for not learning by another's example, as though they were ignoring the available resources to learn a task, as seen in Tz'utujil Maya parents who scolded questioning children and asking "if they had eyes". Children from the Chillihuani village in

6290-616: The time of his death, and published with the half-complete manuscript of The Visible and the Invisible , several make it evident that Merleau-Ponty himself recognized a deep affinity between his notion of a primordial "flesh" and a radically transformed understanding of "nature". Hence, in November 1960 he writes: "Do a psychoanalysis of Nature: it is the flesh, the mother." And in the last published working note, written in March 1961, he writes: "Nature as

6375-556: The topic. In German, his writings on intersubjectivity are gathered in volumes 13–15 of the Husserliana . In English, his best-known text on intersubjectivity is the Cartesian Meditations (it is this text that features solely in the Husserl reader entitled The Essential Husserl ). Although Husserlian phenomenology is often charged with methodological solipsism , in the fifth Cartesian Meditation, Husserl attempts to grapple with

6460-501: The traditional view of cognitive science. Dreyfus's seminal critique of cognitivism (or the computational account of the mind), What Computers Can't Do , consciously replays Merleau-Ponty's critique of intellectualist psychology to argue for the irreducibility of corporeal know-how to discrete, syntactic processes. Through the influence of Dreyfus's critique and neurophysiological alternative, Merleau-Ponty became associated with neurophysiological, connectionist accounts of cognition. With

6545-423: The very rapid cultural development of new born infants. Research suggests that as babies, humans are biologically wired to "coordinate their actions with others". This ability to coordinate and sync with others facilitates cognitive and emotional learning through social interaction. Additionally, the most socially productive relationship between children and adults is bidirectional, where both parties actively define

6630-505: The world's things. The world and the sense of self are emergent phenomena in an ongoing "becoming". The essential partiality of the view of things, their being given only in a certain perspective and at a certain moment in time does not diminish their reality, but on the contrary establishes it, as there is no other way for things to be copresent in the world and with other things than through such " Abschattungen " (sketches, faint outlines, adumbrations). The thing transcends perception, but

6715-524: Was a French phenomenological philosopher , strongly influenced by Edmund Husserl and Martin Heidegger . The constitution of meaning in human experience was his main interest and he wrote on perception , art , politics , religion , biology , psychology , psychoanalysis , language , nature , and history . He was the lead editor of Les Temps modernes , the leftist magazine he established with Jean-Paul Sartre and Simone de Beauvoir in 1945. At

6800-518: Was a pseudonym of the 20-year-old Merleau-Ponty. Merleau-Ponty taught first at the Lycée de Beauvais (1931–33) and then got a fellowship to do research from the Caisse nationale de la recherche scientifique  [ fr ] . From 1934 to 1935 he taught at the Lycée de Chartres . He then in 1935 became a tutor at the École Normale Supérieure, where he tutored a young Michel Foucault and Trần Đức Thảo and

6885-477: Was also political editor for the leftist journal Les Temps modernes from its founding in October 1945 until December 1952. In his youth, he had read Karl Marx 's writings and Sartre even claimed that Merleau-Ponty converted him to Marxism . E. K. Kuby states that while Merleau-Ponty was not a member of the French Communist Party and did not identify as a Communist, he laid out an argument justifying

6970-490: Was awarded his doctorate on the basis of two important books: La structure du comportement (1942) and Phénoménologie de la Perception (1945). During this time, he attended Alexandre Kojeve 's influential seminars on Hegel and Aron Gurwitsch 's lectures on Gestalt psychology . In the spring of 1939, he was the first foreign visitor to the newly established Husserl Archives , where he consulted Husserl's unpublished manuscripts and met Eugen Fink and Herman Van Breda . In

7055-837: Was five years old. After secondary schooling at the Lycée Louis-le-Grand in Paris , Merleau-Ponty became a student at the École Normale Supérieure, where he studied alongside Jean-Paul Sartre , Simone de Beauvoir , Simone Weil , Jean Hyppolite , and Jean Wahl . As Beauvoir recounts in her autobiography, she developed a close friendship with Merleau-Ponty and became smitten with him, but ultimately found him too well-adjusted to bourgeois life and values for her taste. He attended Edmund Husserl 's "Paris Lectures" in February 1929. In 1929, Merleau-Ponty received his DES degree ( diplôme d'études supérieures  [ fr ] , roughly equivalent to

7140-450: Was not the causal product of atomic sensations . This atomist-causal conception was being perpetuated in certain psychological currents of the time, particularly in behaviourism . According to Merleau-Ponty, perception has an active dimension, in that it is a primordial openness to the lifeworld (the " Lebenswelt "). This primordial openness is at the heart of his thesis of the primacy of perception. The slogan of Husserl's phenomenology

7225-433: Was stated in his Preface to the Phenomenology : he described scientific points of view as "always both naive and at the same time dishonest". Despite, or perhaps because of, this view, his work influenced and anticipated the strands of modern psychology known as post-cognitivism . Hubert Dreyfus has been instrumental in emphasising the relevance of Merleau-Ponty's work to current post-cognitive research, and its criticism of

#742257